Hand holding a silver coin with eagle and wreath design, blurred background, close-up view

10 Rare Coins That Could Be Sitting in Your Junk Drawer

If you’ve ever rummaged through your junk drawer, you might be surprised to learn that some coins hiding in there could be worth quite a bit. Many people don’t realize that everyday pocket change can hold hidden treasures that collectors seek. You might just stumble upon a rare coin that could fetch a significant sum on the market.

This article explores ten of the most sought-after rare coins that could be lurking in your home. By checking your loose change and old coin collections, you may find something invaluable that adds excitement to your collection or helps boost your finances. ]

1. 1943 Copper Penny

Three Lincoln coins in a white cardboard holder, placed on a textured white surface, showing different levels of shine and wear
Image credit: ebay.

The 1943 Copper Penny is a rare find for coin collectors. During World War II, pennies were typically made from steel due to a copper shortage. However, a small number of copper pennies were mistakenly struck that year.

If you have a 1943 penny, check its weight. Copper pennies weigh about 3.11 grams, while steel ones weigh around 2.7 grams. If your penny is magnetic, it’s not the rare version.

This unique coin can be worth a significant amount, sometimes over $100,000, especially in excellent condition. Keep an eye on your change—you might just have a hidden treasure!

2. 1969-S Lincoln Penny

Close-up of a 1969 Lincoln penny, front and back sides displayed, showing Abraham Lincoln’s profile on the obverse, the Lincoln Memorial on the reverse
Imaged credit. ebay.

The 1969-S Lincoln Penny might be worth more than you think. If you come across this coin, check for the rare 1969-S Doubled Die variety.

This particular penny features a noticeable doubling of the lettering on the obverse. Fewer than 100 authentic coins exist, making it quite valuable, potentially worth over $126,500.

Even if it’s just a standard 1969-S penny, it still holds some value. Worn examples are typically worth about 2 cents due to their copper content. Keep an eye out for this little treasure in your change jar!

3. 1913 Liberty Head Nickel

A collection of Liberty Head "V" nickels, dated between 1900 and 1902, silver in color, featuring Lady Liberty on the obverse and a large Roman numeral "V" on the reverse
Imaged credit: ebay.

The 1913 Liberty Head Nickel is a legendary coin that every collector dreams of finding. Only five of these nickels were ever minted, making them incredibly rare.

If you happen to find one, it could be worth millions. This nickel is famous for its unauthorized production and unique history.

Collectors prize it not just for its value but also for its intriguing story. Keep an eye on your change; you never know what hidden treasures might be waiting!

4. 1983 No Mint Mark Penny

Close-up of a 1983 Lincoln penny, held between fingers, showing the obverse side with Abraham Lincoln’s profile, copper-colored surface with visible wear
Image credit: ebay.

The 1983 No Mint Mark Penny is a fascinating find. Minted in Philadelphia, it features the Lincoln Memorial design and is made primarily of zinc.

While it was produced in large quantities—over 7.75 billion—some coins have unique qualities that set them apart. In good condition, they can be worth about $0.05, but pristine examples may fetch much more.

Keep an eye out for any rare errors with this coin. Some have sold for thousands at auction, making your junk drawer a potential treasure trove.

5. 2004 Wisconsin State Quarter with Extra Leaf

2004 Wisconsin state quarter, features a cow, a wheel of cheese, and an ear of corn, commemorates Wisconsin's agriculture and dairy industry, silver-toned coin, black background
Image credit: ebay.

The 2004 Wisconsin State Quarter with Extra Leaf is a notable coin among collectors. This unique variety features an additional leaf on the corn stalk, which distinguishes it from the standard design.

You might find two versions: the High Leaf and the Low Leaf. The Low Leaf variant is particularly sought after by numismatists.

If you happen to have this quarter, it could be worth a significant amount—up to $500,000 in some cases. So, check your drawers; you might have a rare treasure!

6. 1804 Silver Dollar

Two silver Morgan dollar coins, one showing the obverse with Lady Liberty's profile and the year 1893, the other displaying the reverse with an eagle holding arrows and an olive branch
Image credit: ebay.

The 1804 Silver Dollar is often referred to as the “King of American Coins.” Its rarity makes it highly sought after by collectors like you.

Although it is dated 1804, this coin was actually minted in the 1830s. It was created as part of diplomatic gifts during Andrew Jackson’s presidency.

Only 15 known examples exist, making it extremely valuable. If you come across one in your junk drawer, you might have a treasure on your hands.

7. 1927-D Double Eagle

Gold coin in a protective graded case, coin features intricate design and inscriptions, encapsulated for preservation and authentication
Image credit: ebay.

The 1927-D Double Eagle is a remarkable coin that could be hiding in your junk drawer. Minted in Denver, it features a stunning design by Augustus Saint-Gaudens.

This gold coin is known for its rarity; estimates suggest only about 14 to 15 of these coins still exist today. Due to its limited supply, it’s highly sought after by collectors.

In recent years, a 1927-D Double Eagle sold for an impressive $3.84 million, showcasing its significant value. If you discover one, you may be holding a treasure worth a small fortune.

8. 1944 Steel Penny

1944 Lincoln wheat penny, copper coin, features Abraham Lincoln’s profile, year "1944" on the right, well-preserved condition, slight wear visible
Image credit: ebay.

The 1944 Steel Penny is a fascinating coin that you might find in your collection. Struck during World War II, these pennies were made from steel instead of the usual copper due to metal shortages.

Only a few examples of the 1944 Steel Penny exist, making them quite rare. If you have one, it could fetch significant value, potentially over $100,000, depending on its condition.

To check your penny, look for the weight and the mint mark. Authenticating with a coin grading service is a smart step for collectors. Keep an eye out—you could have a treasure in your junk drawer!

9. 1992 Close AM Penny

A 1992-D Lincoln penny, copper-colored, features Abraham Lincoln's profile facing right, , and the year "1992" with a "D" mintmark to the right
Image credit: ebay.

The 1992 Close AM Penny could be hiding in your collection. This coin features a unique error where the letters “A” and “M” in “America” are close together, unlike typical pennies where they are spaced apart.

If you have one, it could be worth a significant amount. Some of these rare coins have sold for over $20,000, especially those in better condition. Check your 1992 pennies carefully; you might be in for a surprise!

10. 1879 $4 Stella Gold Coin

A gold coin dated 1878, featuring a left-facing Lady Liberty with a coronet, surrounded by stars and inscriptions, set against an American flag background
Image credit: ebay.

The 1879 $4 Stella gold coin is a unique piece that you might find in an old collection. This coin was designed to promote a new denomination that could be useful for international trade.

With a mintage of only 425 coins, it’s considered rare and collectible. The coin features the Flowing Hair design and holds a composition of 85.7% gold.

If you happen to have one, it could be worth a significant amount. Check its condition and consider reaching out to a reputable coin dealer for an evaluation.