If you grew up in the ’90s, you might be surprised to learn that some of your childhood toys could be worth a lot more than you ever expected. Many of these toys have become collectibles, fetching thousands of dollars today.
The value of these toys comes from their rarity, condition, and the nostalgia they hold for collectors. Whether you’ve kept them packed away or recently rediscovered them, there’s a chance you’re sitting on more than just old toys.
Original Super Soaker 50
If you grew up in the ’90s, you might remember the Super Soaker 50. It was one of the first water guns to use pressurized air for powerful water jets.
Today, finding an original Super Soaker 50 in good condition can be a real treat. If it’s still working and especially if it includes the original box and manual, it can be worth between $100 and $300.
Collectors love its nostalgic design and how it changed summer playtime. Your old Super Soaker 50 might surprise you with its value.
First Edition Harry Potter Book
If you have a first edition hardback of Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, it could be valuable. Look for the print line with numbers counting down from 10 to 1 on the title page.
Only about 500 of these first printings exist, so they’re quite rare. Some copies have sold for tens of thousands of dollars.
Check your bookshelf carefully—you might be sitting on a small treasure!
Princess the Bear Beanie Baby
If you have a Princess the Bear Beanie Baby, it might catch some attention. Created in 1997 to honor Princess Diana, it’s a popular collectible from the 90s.
While some listings ask for high prices, realistic sales usually range between $50 and $200. You can spot fakes by checking details like the eyes and tags carefully. It’s a neat piece of 90s nostalgia, but don’t expect thousands of dollars for it.
Peanut the Elephant Beanie Baby
If you grew up in the 90s, you might remember Peanut the Elephant. This Beanie Baby first appeared in a royal blue color in 1995.
Finding one in mint condition can be exciting, as some versions are worth several thousand dollars. The light blue variant, introduced later, is especially rare and valuable.
If you have Peanut tucked away, it’s worth checking its color and condition. You might be sitting on a small treasure from the 90s!
Mighty Morphin Power Rangers Megazord
If you had a Mighty Morphin Power Rangers Megazord toy in the 90s, you know how special it was. This iconic figure let you recreate the big battles from the show right at home.
Today, some Megazord sets, especially in good condition, can be worth a lot. Collectors look for figures that still have their original parts and packaging.
Finding one now might take some effort, but it can be a cool addition to your collection or a smart investment.
LEGO Pirates Special Edition Set
If you loved LEGO in the ’90s, the Pirates Special Edition sets might catch your eye. These sets, especially the Black Seas Barracuda and Skull’s Eye Schooner, have become quite valuable.
You might find that sealed versions sell for thousands today. Their detailed ships and minifigures make them a treasure for collectors and fans alike. If you have one, it’s worth checking its condition and current market value.
LEGO Castle Retired Set
If you have a LEGO Castle set from the 1990s, it might be worth more than you expect. These sets were part of exciting themes like Black Knights and Crusaders.
Back then, they cost around $150, but today, collectors value them at several thousand dollars.
Since these sets are no longer produced, your retired LEGO Castle could be a rare find. Keep it in good condition to maximize its value.
1990s Pikachu Handheld Gaming System
If you have a Pikachu-themed handheld gaming system from the ’90s, it could be worth a lot today. These devices were popular back then and have become collector’s items.
The combination of nostalgia and rarity drives their value. If yours is in good condition or unopened, it might sell for thousands. Keep an eye on platforms like eBay to see what similar items are going for.
De Beers 40th Anniversary Barbie Doll
If you’re a collector, the De Beers 40th Anniversary Barbie from 1999 is a standout. This Barbie was dressed in a gown adorned with real diamonds, making it truly special.
Only one of these dolls exists, and it sold for around $85,000 at auction. Its value reflects both the diamonds and the rarity. If you own this Barbie, you might be sitting on a valuable treasure.
Scratch The Cat Action Figure
If you grew up in the ’90s, you might remember Scratch The Cat from Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. This figure wasn’t a main character, but it’s become a rare find for collectors.
Today, Scratch The Cat action figures can sell for around $10,000. If you have one in good condition, it might be worth checking out its value.
Vintage McDonald’s Happy Meal Toys
If you grew up in the ’90s, you probably have memories of those small, plastic McDonald’s toys. Many of these Happy Meal toys have become collectibles today.
Some toys from the ’80s and ’90s, especially limited editions or those tied to popular movies, can be worth a lot. You might want to check your old collection; a few pieces could surprise you with their value.