Thrift stores are part treasure hunt, part time capsule—and the best scores are often hiding on the most ordinary racks and shelves. Beyond everyday basics, sleepers like vintage band tees, first-edition books, vinyl, retro video games, antique jewelry, Pyrex, designer clothing, collectible toys, old coins and banknotes, vintage advertising signs, and even antique furniture can turn a quick stop into a serious win.
As you browse, focus on condition, completeness, and authenticity. Look for single-stitch hems and real tour dates on tees; first-edition “points” and intact dust jackets on books; clean vinyl with readable runout/matrix etchings; complete-in-box (CIB) seals on games; precious-metal hallmarks on jewelry; correct pattern names and matching lids on Pyrex; maker labels and quality construction on designer wear and furniture; original accessories/packaging on toys; and dates, mint marks, and security features on coins and notes. When in doubt, check recent sold listings on your phone and use the trusted guides below before you buy.
1. Vintage Band T-Shirts
When scouring clothing racks at thrift stores, many disregard the array of vintage band t-shirts. These items, often overlooked due to their worn appearance and faded graphics, can hold significant value. Particularly, shirts from concerts in the ’70s and ’80s, can fetch high prices amongst collectors and vintage clothing enthusiasts.
Right now, the market for vintage band t-shirts is booming. Due to the resurgence of ’80s and ’90s fashion trends and the nostalgia associated with classic rock bands, these items have seen a significant increase in demand. According to coverage of recent auction results by Consequence, certain vintage rock tees have set record prices at auction.
2. First Edition Books
Thrift stores are often a treasure trove for book lovers. While most shoppers are looking for a good read, savvy collectors know that first edition books can be worth a small fortune. These books, usually the first run of a title published, are highly valued for their rarity and historical significance.
The market for first edition books has always been strong, but it’s seeing renewed interest as more people get into book collecting. For identification tips and what makes a “true first,” see AbeBooks’ guide to first editions.
3. Vinyl Records
In an era of digital music, vinyl records might seem like a thing of the past. However, these items, often overlooked at thrift stores, can be worth quite a bit. Depending on the artist and the rarity of the record, vinyl can fetch a pretty penny amongst collectors and music enthusiasts.
The demand for vinyl has been growing for years. The RIAA’s 2024 Year-End report notes that vinyl continues a nearly 20-year surge and outsold CDs in units.
4. Retro Video Games
Old video games, often ignored due to their outdated graphics and systems, can be worth a fortune. Collectors and gamers are willing to pay high prices for these games, especially if they are rare or in good condition.
With the rise of nostalgia-driven gaming and the popularity of retro consoles, the market for these games is booming. A Heritage Auctions report shows a sealed copy of Super Mario 64 selling for $1.56 million, underscoring the potential.
5. Antique Jewelry
Antique jewelry can often be found tucked away in thrift stores, overlooked due to its old-fashioned style or tarnished appearance. However, these pieces often hold significant value, especially if they are made of precious metals or contain rare gemstones.
The demand for antique jewelry is increasing, driven by trends in vintage fashion and sustainable shopping. See Sotheby’s on the allure of vintage jewelry for context on why these pieces endure.
6. Vintage Pyrex
While many pass by the kitchenware section in thrift stores, collectors know the real value of vintage Pyrex dishes. Known for their durability and colorful designs, these items can be worth a lot, especially if they are part of a discontinued series or in excellent condition.
According to Bon Appétit, interest in vintage Pyrex has surged, with coveted patterns regularly drawing strong prices online.
7. Designer Clothing
Designer clothing, often donated because of changes in fashion trends or sizing, can be a goldmine in thrift stores. These items, even if they’re a few seasons old, retain their value due to the quality of materials and craftsmanship.
As more consumers turn to secondhand shopping for sustainable and affordable fashion, demand has increased. ThredUp’s annual Resale Report tracks the rapid growth of the secondhand apparel market.
8. Collectible Toys
Thrift stores often have a wealth of toys that are overlooked by many. Collectible toys, especially those from the ’80s and ’90s, can be worth a significant amount, particularly if they are still in their original packaging.
The market for vintage toys is thriving, driven by nostalgia. Recent auction headlines include a rare 1978 Luke Skywalker action figure selling for over $160,000, per Yahoo Sports.
9. Old Coins and Banknotes
Many people overlook old coins and banknotes at thrift stores, but they can be quite valuable. The value of these items can vary greatly, depending on factors such as age, rarity, condition, and historical significance.
With rising interest in numismatics, the market for these items has grown. The U.S. Mint’s collecting basics is a great starting point.
10. Vintage Advertising Signs
Old advertising signs, often dismissed as junk, can actually be worth a lot of money. These items, especially those from the mid-20th century, are in high demand among collectors for their vintage appeal and historical significance.
For background and market insight, see Collectors Weekly’s overview of vintage signs.
11. Antique Furniture
Another treasure that can be found in thrift stores is antique furniture. While these items may require a bit of restoration, they can hold significant value, especially if they are from a recognized period or maker.
As the trend towards sustainable living continues, more people are seeking out antique furniture for its craftsmanship and design. For tips on what to look for, check Christie’s guide to antique furniture.