You might be surprised to learn that some of the toys you played with as a kid have significantly increased in value over the years. Many childhood favorites, if kept in good condition, can now be worth a considerable amount of money.
This article highlights 12 childhood toys that are now worth a fortune, showing you which ones could be valuable today. Whether you’re thinking about digging through your attic or just curious, it’s interesting to see how these nostalgic items turned into prized collectibles.
Original Gameboy
If you still have your original Gameboy, it could be worth more than you think. Collectors look for units in good condition, especially with the original packaging.
Games and special editions add extra value. For example, a Gameboy Color or bundled sets can fetch higher prices.
Finding your old device might be a fun trip down memory lane—and maybe even a small fortune. Keep it safe and check its condition!
Pokemon Cards
If you still have your old Pokémon cards, they might be worth more than you think. Some rare cards from the 90s have gained value, especially if they are in good condition.
Prices can vary a lot depending on the card’s rarity and condition. It’s a good idea to check online marketplaces or get your cards appraised if you want to know their current worth.
Beanie Babies
Beanie Babies are small, stuffed toys that became highly collectible in the 1990s. Some rare editions can be worth hundreds or even thousands of dollars today.
If you still have Beanie Babies in good condition, especially special editions like Princess or Piccadilly, they might be worth checking out. Their value depends on rarity and condition, so keeping them mint is key.
Collectors often hold onto these toys, which keeps demand steady and prices higher. It’s a fun reminder of your childhood with some potential value.
Polly Pocket Sets
If you have vintage Polly Pocket sets from the 1990s, they might be worth quite a bit today. Collectors especially look for original Bluebird sets, which can sell for thousands of dollars.
You’ll find that Disney-themed Polly Pocket toys from the same era also hold good value. Keeping your sets in good condition can make a big difference in what you can get for them.
Furbies
If you have an original Furby from 1998 tucked away, it could be worth quite a bit. Unopened versions have sold for around $900.
Even used Furbies still hold value, usually between $30 and $60 in good condition. Broken ones might fetch about $20.
These interactive toys were hugely popular and are now nostalgic collectibles for many people.
Super Soakers
If you still have your old Super Soaker from the 90s, it might be worth more than you think. Collectors value these water guns for their vibrant colors and nostalgic appeal.
A well-preserved Super Soaker in full working order can fetch between $100 and $500.
So, next time you come across one in good condition, consider its potential as a valuable childhood treasure.
Tamagotchis
If you still have a Tamagotchi from the 90s, it might be worth more than you think. Original sealed versions can sell for several hundred dollars, sometimes over $500.
Even used models that work well can fetch a good price, usually between $40 and $110.
Certain rare editions, like the Yasashii Blue or P’s Pink, are especially valuable and could be worth up to $1,000. Keep yours safe!
Yu-Gi-Oh! Cards
If you have old Yu-Gi-Oh! cards, some could be worth a lot. Cards like Harpie’s Feather Duster are rare and highly sought after.
Certain holographic cards and tournament exclusives can fetch high prices, especially in good condition. Check your collection carefully, as a few valuable cards might be hiding among the common ones.
G.I. Joe Action Figures
If you have G.I. Joe action figures from the 1960s or 1980s, they could be worth quite a bit. Early prototypes from 1964 are especially valuable to collectors.
Even figures without all their accessories can fetch prices around $50 or more today. It’s worth checking the condition and rarity of your G.I. Joe toys if you’re curious about their potential value.
My Little Pony Generation One
If you still have some Generation One My Little Ponies, you might want to take a closer look. These ponies, especially the original six like Blossom and Blue Belle, can be quite valuable.
You’ll find that rare variants and internationally released figures often fetch higher prices. Collectors appreciate the strong nostalgia and unique designs from this era.
Finding these ponies in good condition or with original accessories can make your collection even more desirable.
Rare Pez Dispensers
If you have a vintage Pez dispenser, it might be more valuable than you think. The 1955 Santa Claus head dispenser is one of the rarest and can be worth tens of thousands of dollars.
Another highly sought-after model is the Astronaut B from the 1982 World’s Fair, which sold for over $30,000. Keep an eye out for unique designs or limited editions, as they often increase in value over time.
Thundercats Lion-O Action Figure
If you have a Lion-O action figure from the original 1985 Thundercats series, it could be valuable. Sealed and well-preserved figures have sold for prices near $900 or even more.
Even used ones can attract collectors, especially if they come with original accessories. You might find some selling for hundreds or over two thousand dollars, depending on condition and rarity. Keep an eye on online marketplaces if you want to check current prices.