Crop positive ethnic females examining creative glass teacup standing near table with collection of various dishware in store

14 Everyday Things That Became Collector Favorites

Many items you use every day can gain unexpected value over time. What once seemed ordinary or overlooked can become highly sought after by collectors.

Understanding which everyday things have become collector favorites can help you spot hidden treasures in your own home. This article will give you a glimpse into how simple household items have turned into prized collectibles.

Vintage teacups from around the world

Crop positive ethnic females examining creative glass teacup standing near table with collection of various dishware in store
Photo by Sam Lion from Pexels

You can find vintage teacups from many countries, each with its own unique style. Whether from England, Japan, or France, these cups often feature delicate designs and fine materials like porcelain or bone china.

When shopping, look for pieces in good condition. Rare designs or those in mint shape can be more valuable. You might discover vintage teacups priced between $20 and $100 or more depending on rarity and condition.

Explore collections online or at specialty shops to find treasures that suit your taste and add charm to your daily tea time. Check out antique options on sites like Etsy for a variety of choices.

Classic baseball cards

Assorted hockey trading cards in plastic sleeves, featuring vintage and modern players, some autographed, scattered on a flat surface
Image credit: Erik Mclean/Pexels.

If you have classic baseball cards, you’re holding a piece of sports history. Cards from the prewar and postwar eras often feature iconic players and timeless designs.

You might already treasure the stories behind your cards, like many collectors do. Some cards stand out because of their artistic portraits or colorful backgrounds.

For more on favorite vintage cards and what makes them special, check out this vintage baseball card collection.

Old horror movie posters

Framed vintage Dracula movie poster with Bela Lugosi, bold red and yellow title, mounted on brick wall
Image credit: Lost Island Trading Company/eBay.

You might be surprised how popular old horror movie posters have become with collectors. These posters often feature vivid artwork with eerie landscapes and creepy silhouettes.

If you enjoy vintage style, you’ll find these posters offer a unique glimpse into past movie marketing. Collectors love hunting for originals from the 70s, 80s, and 90s.

Buying one can feel like holding a piece of horror history. Check out collections for styles that match your favorite movies and add a spooky touch to your space. For examples, visit a collector’s guide to vintage horror movie posters.

National Pottery Co. “Cookies All Over” jars

Image Credit: eBay.

If you come across a National Pottery Co. “Cookies All Over” jar, you might have a hidden gem. These vintage cookie jars often feature colorful cookie designs and a charming style.

You can find jars with cookies decorating the lid and body, sometimes even topped with a walnut-shaped finial. Collectors appreciate their nostalgic look, and some jars sell for up to $75.

Check your parents’ or grandparents’ kitchen cabinets—you might spot one of these collectible pieces in their collection. For more details, see this overview of valuable cookie jars.

Rare coins

euro coins scattered on wooden table, some coins mid-air, various denominations visible, motion blur, close-up shot
Image credit: ClickerHappy/Pexels.

You might have rare coins hiding in your pocket change without realizing it. Some like the 1909-S VDB Lincoln Cent or the 1943 bronze planchet penny are highly sought after by collectors.

Even certain quarters, such as the 2004 Wisconsin Extra Leaf variety, can be valuable. Keep an eye out—you never know which coin could catch a collector’s interest. For more details, check out these rare coins wanted by collectors.

Vintage hats

Two young boys wearing colorful bucket hats and suspenders sit on the bumper of a vintage light blue car. They're dressed similarly in t-shirts and jeans with matching suspenders against a rustic backdrop
Image Credit:Vika Glitter/Pexels.

You might be surprised how vintage hats have become popular collector’s items. These hats show unique styles and craftsmanship that you rarely see today.

Finding one with detailed embroidery or quality velvet can make your collection stand out. You can explore collections that feature classic snapbacks or elegant ladies’ chapeaus from the mid-twentieth century. If you love trying different styles, vintage hats give you a timeless look that’s hard to match.

High heel shoes collection

Image Credit: Pexels.

If you love fashion, building a high heel shoes collection can be fun and rewarding. You might find vintage mini high heels that add a unique touch to your wardrobe.

Your collection can include styles from affordable options to standout pieces. Organizing them well keeps your favorites easy to find and ready to wear.

Miniature cars

Close-up of colorful toy race cars arranged in rows on a wooden surface, featuring various models and designs
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

You might already have some miniature cars around without realizing their collector value. These small models, like Hot Wheels or detailed diecasts, often capture real car designs in tiny form.

If you enjoy cars, collecting miniatures can be a fun way to explore rare and unique models. Some miniatures, especially limited editions, become favorites among collectors. You can find inspiration from enthusiasts sharing collections, like those who showcase rare diecast cars on YouTube or Reddit.

Comic books

Pair of sneakers standing over scattered Marvel comic books, visible Deadpool and Silver Surfer covers, indoor carpet background
Image credit: Erik Mclean/Pexels.

You might not expect comic books to become prized collectibles, but many have over time. Titles like Neil Gaiman’s Sandman and Alan Moore’s Swamp Thing are favorites among collectors.

Certain issues, like The Coming of Galactus or Kraven’s Last Hunt, have gained special status. If you have these, they could be valuable to others too. Exploring iconic series can be a fun way to start your collection and see what stands out to you.

For more on iconic comic books collectors seek, check out this list of holy grail comics.

Vintage movie posters

Image Credit: Pexels.

You might be surprised how much vintage movie posters have become collector favorites. Posters from classic films like Metropolis and Dracula can fetch high prices today.

If you have any old movie posters hanging around, they could be worth looking into. Many collectors prize these for their artistic and nostalgic value.

To see some examples of valuable posters, check out this list of 15 vintage movie posters that are now collector’s gold.

Antique jewelry

Art Deco Jewelry Pieces
Image credit: Adnan Mirza / Unsplash

You’ll find antique jewelry holds a special charm for collectors. Pieces from eras like Victorian, Edwardian, and Art Deco offer unique designs and craftsmanship you rarely see today.

Many collectors look for vintage costume jewelry made from materials like Bakelite or Lucite, which have become collectible over time.

Crystals and gemstones

Image Credit: Pexels.

You might be surprised how everyday crystals and gemstones become collector favorites. Many people start with simple kits that let you dig up real gemstones, like a fun learning activity for kids and adults alike.

Collecting these stones can connect you to nature and history, especially when you find semi-precious or rare gems. Some popular choices, like amethyst or fluorite, are loved for both their beauty and unique properties.

Fine wines

Person uncorking wine bottle with corkscrew, wine glass beside, dimly lit background, close-up of hands
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

You might think wine is just for special occasions, but certain bottles have become popular collectibles. Wines like Jacques Perrin and Haut Brion attract attention because of their consistent quality and reputation.

If you enjoy gathering wines, consider building a collection with a mix of everyday favorites and renowned labels. A tasting set featuring different varietals can also help you explore new flavors and decide what to keep.

Vintage tin boxes

Vintage Inch High Private Eye lunchbox, cartoon characters on metal surface, blue trim, red handle, retro design
Image credit: Wendi’s Collectibles Plus/eBay.

You might be surprised how charming vintage tin boxes can be as collectibles. They often feature nostalgic illustrations or advertising from past decades, making them visually appealing.

These boxes were once everyday storage solutions for things like cookies or popcorn. Now, they’re sought after for their history and unique designs. If you like something both practical and collectible, vintage tin boxes could be a great choice for your collection. Check out different styles and sizes to find one that fits your taste.