If you’re thinking about clearing out old toys from your home, it’s a good idea to pause and take a closer look at what you have. Many vintage toys hold unexpected value, and some could be worth more than you might guess. Knowing which toys could bring in some extra cash before you let them go can make decluttering much more rewarding.
Toys often carry nostalgic memories, but they can also have collectible appeal for buyers and hobbyists. Before you decide to donate or toss them, checking the value of certain items can save you from missing out on a worthwhile find. This guide will help you consider the toys that are commonly valuable and worth checking first.
My Little Pony figures
If you have My Little Pony figures from the ’80s, especially Generation 1, they might be worth checking before decluttering. Some older ponies can hold value, depending on their condition and rarity.
Newer generations generally have less value, but unique or limited ponies could be exceptions. Take some time to identify which ones you have.
Even if you just want to clear space, a quick value check can help you avoid accidentally letting go of something valuable.
First-generation Tamagotchi
If you have an original first-generation Tamagotchi, it might be worth more than you expect. Some sets, especially those in good condition or still in the box, can sell for several hundred to over two thousand dollars.
Check the condition and version you have before deciding to part with it. Doing a quick online search can help you find current prices and see if yours is valuable.
1997 Princess Diana Beanie Baby
If you have a 1997 Princess Diana Beanie Baby, it might catch your interest to know it was made in memory of Princess Diana. Many people love its purple color and the story behind it.
However, don’t expect it to be extremely rare. Millions were produced, so its value usually isn’t very high. Still, if it’s in mint condition, some collectors might pay around $100 to $200.
Check the tag and overall condition before deciding to keep or sell it.
Humphrey the Camel Beanie Baby
If you have Humphrey the Camel, it might be more valuable than you think. This Beanie Baby was one of the first to be retired, so fewer were made.
Because of its rarity, collectors often look for Humphrey in good condition. Before decluttering, check if your Humphrey has its original tags, as this can affect the price.
Magic: The Gathering 1993 cards
If you have Magic: The Gathering cards from 1993, you might want to check their value before decluttering. Some cards, like the Black Lotus, are highly sought after by collectors and can be worth a lot.
Other early cards like Time Walk and Ancestral Recall also have significant value. Even some less famous cards have increased in price over time.
Before you toss your old decks, it’s a good idea to look up each card or get them appraised. It could turn out they’re worth more than you think.
Cabbage Patch Kids dolls
If you find Cabbage Patch Kids dolls in your home, don’t rush to toss them. Some original and limited-edition dolls can be worth quite a bit, sometimes up to a few thousand dollars.
Check for unique features like original tags or special editions. These details can raise a doll’s value. Take a moment to research before you declutter.
Optimus Prime Transformers
If you have an original Optimus Prime Transformer, it might be worth more than you think. Figures from the 1980s, especially those with trailers, can fetch a good price if they are in good condition.
Even loose figures can have some value, but having the original box usually increases what collectors will pay. Before you declutter, check your figure’s condition and packaging to see if it’s worth keeping.
My Buddy dolls
If you have a My Buddy doll, it might be worth a quick check before you declutter. These dolls were popular thanks to a catchy jingle and have some collectible value.
Depending on the condition and rarity, your My Buddy doll could be worth between $100 and $300. Keep an eye out for any unique features or original packaging to increase value.
G.I. Joe action figures
If you have G.I. Joe figures from the 1980s, they might be worth checking out before you declutter. Some figures and playsets can sell for a good amount, especially if they are in their original packaging.
Look closely at the condition of your toys. Figures with weapons, cards, or in Toys “R” Us exclusive sets can be more valuable.
Even loose figures might have some value, but boxed or carded items tend to attract collectors more. It’s a good idea to compare prices online before deciding what to keep or sell.
Teddy Ruxpin talking bear
If you have a Teddy Ruxpin talking bear, you might want to check its condition before deciding to declutter. Original models from 1985 can be worth anywhere from $30 to over $1,000, depending on whether it works and if it comes with tapes or books.
Newer versions feature advanced technology like color LCD eyes, but older ones hold more collectible value. Keep your bear safe and see if it’s a hidden gem before letting it go.
Troll dolls
If you have some old Troll dolls, it’s worth checking their value before you declutter. Dolls from the 1960s or 1990s can sell for hundreds, sometimes even more.
Look out for original versions with features like bright hair and unique faces. Some have recently sold for close to $1,000 or more, depending on condition.
Even smaller or less rare Troll dolls can bring in decent prices when grouped together. Definitely take a moment to see what yours could be worth.
Vintage PEZ dispensers
If you have vintage PEZ dispensers, don’t rush to toss them. Some can be surprisingly valuable, especially those from the 1950s like the Space Gun dispenser.
Look for dispensers without feet, as they often date back further and can be worth more.
Even small collections can add up in value. Check each piece before you decide to declutter.
Barbie dolls and accessories
If you have old Barbie dolls or accessories, don’t rush to toss them out. Some vintage Barbies, especially those in their original boxes and good condition, can be quite valuable.
You’ll want to check the year and model before deciding. Rare or limited-edition Barbies often attract collectors and can sell for a good price.
Keep in mind that dolls that show signs of play or damage usually won’t be worth as much. Accessories can add value, but rely on their condition and rarity too.
American Girl dolls
If you have old American Girl dolls, don’t rush to toss them out. Some models, especially those from the ’80s and ’90s, can be worth money if they are in good condition with original clothes.
You might find your doll listed for anywhere from $35 to over $100 online. It’s worth checking the current market before deciding what to do with your collection.
Original Gameboys
If you find an original Gameboy, it’s worth checking its condition before deciding. These handheld consoles typically sell for around $65 to $75 each on the market.
Games like Pokémon for the Gameboy can be even more valuable, often reaching $200 or more. Other titles, like Super Mario, usually sell for less but still have some value.
Make sure to keep your Gameboy and games in good shape to get the best price if you decide to sell.
Like what you read? Here’s more by us: