If you’ve ever come across vintage Pyrex in a thrift shop or your grandma’s kitchen, you might wonder if it’s worth anything. I’ve spent some time digging into which pieces collectors really want and why some of these dishes command high prices.
The truth is, certain vintage Pyrex items can sell for thousands of dollars, making them valuable finds beyond just nostalgic kitchenware. Whether you’re casually hunting or seriously collecting, knowing which patterns and styles stand out can make all the difference.
Pink Amish Butterprint
I’ve always been drawn to the Pink Amish Butterprint pattern. It’s a charming vintage Pyrex design from the late ’50s and early ’60s that features a simple, rustic pink and white print.
This pattern was a special edition following the original turquoise Butterprint, and it shows on various casserole dishes in a few sizes.
Collectors often seek this set, especially complete ones, since it can fetch a high price. I found some listings for it with prices ranging pretty widely depending on condition and pieces included. You can check out Pink Amish Butterprint dishes for sale on eBay if you want to see the current market.
Turquoise Golden Birds
I’ve always been drawn to the Turquoise Golden Birds pattern. It dates back to the 1960s and is pretty rare, especially the 2-quart casserole dish with the matching lid.
These pieces were designed to be rectangular and fit neatly in fridges, which is a neat little detail. I’ve seen some sell for thousands, with a few fetching prices as high as $6,000 or more. It’s definitely one of those Pyrex patterns that catches collectors’ eyes.
If you ever come across one in good shape, it’s worth holding onto or checking its value. You can find more info about Turquoise Golden Birds here.
Blue Dianthus
I find Blue Dianthus to be one of the more mysterious vintage Pyrex patterns. Not many pieces were made or found, which makes them pretty rare.
The pattern includes Cinderella mixing bowls and a few casserole dishes. These date back to before 1974, but the exact production date isn’t clear.
I’ve seen complete sets sell for thousands, especially when they’re in great condition with no chips or cracks. If you come across Blue Dianthus, it’s definitely worth a closer look.
You can learn more about the rarity and details of Blue Dianthus on this Pyrex Blue Dianthus page.
Cinderella Pattern
I find the Cinderella Pattern pretty interesting because it’s one of those vintage Pyrex styles that still gets a lot of attention. The bowls have these unique original handles, which make them stand out compared to other Pyrex pieces.
Most Cinderella pieces sell for around $40 to $80, but some rare shapes or colors can go higher. It was popular up until the Colonial Mist collection in 1983, so it has a good mix of vintage charm and collectibility. You can learn more about it on this detailed Cinderella & Pyrex guide.
Snowflake Garland
I’ve always been drawn to the Snowflake Garland pattern because of its simple white snowflakes on a blue background. It was produced mainly in the early 1970s. The mix of nesting bowls and Cinderella casseroles makes it a versatile set for collectors.
Prices for these pieces can vary a lot. I’ve seen some sell for anywhere from $75 up to several hundred dollars depending on condition and rarity. It’s definitely one of those patterns that stands out if you come across it in vintage shops or online listings like on eBay.
Gooseberry Pattern
I’ve always been drawn to the Gooseberry pattern because of its charming pink berry design. It was used on various Pyrex pieces like bowls, casseroles, and pitchers, which makes collecting it fun.
What’s cool is that the pink Gooseberry items, especially in great condition, tend to be pretty valuable. I’ve seen sets of nesting bowls go for over a hundred dollars. If you spot some in good shape, they can definitely catch a collector’s eye.
For more details on the Gooseberry pattern’s value, you can check out this vintage Pyrex collectibles guide.
Butterprint Dish Set
I’ve always loved the Butterprint Dish Set for its charming farmhouse design. The set usually includes bowls or dishes with the classic Amish couple and pumpkin patterns in bright orange or teal.
Collectors really go after complete sets, which can sell between $200 and $500 depending on condition. Single pieces vary in value, but the nostalgic look keeps them popular. You can often find these pieces listed under Vintage Pyrex Butterprint sets for more info.
