A first grade classroom in Tennessee has abruptly become the latest flashpoint in the national fight over how schools handle LGBTQ topics and religious objections. Eric Rivera, a first grade teacher at a Nashville charter school, says he was pressured to choose between his faith and his job after he declined to read a picture book about a child with two dads. He remains employed, but his account of being threatened with termination has parents, advocates, and lawyers poring over school policies and federal law.
At the center of the conflict is a short classroom read aloud that, in most years, would barely register outside the school walls. This time, Rivera’s refusal has turned that moment into a test case for how far a school can go in enforcing curriculum expectations when a teacher raises a religious objection, and what kind of protection a teacher can claim when that lesson involves an LGBTQ family.
What Happened Inside That Nashville Classroom
Rivera teaches at KIPP Antioch College Prep Elementary, a charter school in Nashville where first graders were set to hear the book “Stella Brings the Family,” a story about a girl who invites her two dads to a school event. The children’s book, which centers on a class assignment about family, has become a common choice in early elementary classrooms that want to acknowledge different family structures, including same sex parents, and a quick search for Stella Brings the shows it marketed as a gentle introduction to that idea. Rivera, who is open about his Christian faith, says he told administrators that reading the book would violate his religious beliefs and asked for a different assignment.
According to Rivera, that request did not go over quietly. He says school leaders told him that refusing the read aloud could be treated as insubordination and that termination was on the table if he did not comply. In a video interview, a clip of which appears in a report about a first grade teacher, Rivera describes being pulled from his regular classroom duties and reassigned after he stood his ground. The book was still read to students by another staff member, he says, but he was no longer the one leading that part of the lesson.
Rivera’s lawyer has framed the dispute as a textbook workplace rights case. In a broadcast segment that lays out the legal argument, his attorney says federal law “primarily” requires employers to offer religious accommodations when they can, and that this should have been treated like any other conflict between job duties and sincerely held beliefs, a point repeated in a separate clip that refers to how attorney says federal protects workers. The school, according to Rivera’s account, instead opened an investigation into his conduct and warned that discipline up to termination could follow, which is what he now describes as a threat to his job.
How a Classroom Read Aloud Turned Into a Culture War Test Case
Once word of the dispute got out, the story left the school building fast. A detailed write up described how a first grade teacher said administrators threatened to fire him for rejecting the LGBTQ themed book and that he is now represented by counsel. That piece identifies him as Eric Rivera and lays out his claim that he was moved from his usual first grade role after the conflict. Around the same time, television coverage repeatedly described a Nashville teacher who refused to read an LGBTQ book and allegedly faced termination, tying the controversy directly to KIPP Antioch College Prep Elementary and to the same title, “Stella Brings the Family.”
One national story on the dispute, written by Madeleine Nolan, describes a Nashville teacher allegedly and places the flashpoint earlier this year, when the lesson was scheduled in January. That account notes that Rivera remains on staff but under a different assignment, and it repeats his claim that he was warned that his refusal could be considered a fireable offense. Another version of the same report, also credited to Madeleine Nolan, highlights that Rivera is seen in ALL PHOTOS from and that the story has been updated as more reaction rolls in.
On social media, the narrative has been sharpened even further. One widely shared Facebook post claimed that “They dismissed this teacher after he refused to read a same sex book to children” and asked followers “What do you guys think?” about a Nashville elementary school that, according to the post, warned that discipline including termination could follow the refusal, language that tracks Rivera’s description of events and is echoed in a thread about how dismissed this teacher. Other coverage, including a version carried on a regional station that repeats the Nashville teacher allegedly framing, has used Rivera’s case to illustrate how LGBTQ inclusive curriculum can collide with employees who say their faith will not let them participate.
The Legal And Cultural Stakes Around Rivera’s Claim
More from Decluttering Mom: