One Reddit user recently shared a deeply unsettling situation: her abusive father, who had been a source of pain throughout her life, was now asking her for a kidney. This request came after years of physical and emotional abuse and a string of broken promises that left her feeling more than hesitant.
Her father had been diagnosed with chronic kidney disease, and he seemed to believe that his daughter owed him a solution. While he had always claimed that his long work hours were about providing for her future—promising money for a house and a car that never materialized—those assurances felt empty now. She felt caught off guard, especially considering the depth of their history.
Having been no contact with him since December 2025, she found the request particularly shocking. The decision to cut ties had been liberating for her, especially after years of trauma stemming from their relationship. Her father’s idea of reaching out for such a significant sacrifice felt like a punch to the gut, highlighting the estrangement that had become essential for her well-being.
Add to that her own health struggles, including a previous cancer diagnosis and a history of alcoholism, and it was impossible to see how donating a kidney could be an option. The thought process behind his demand—believing that a single kidney would make her higher on a transplant list—was not only misguided but also indicative of his lack of understanding of her own experiences.
People had very different reactions to her story online. Some expressed disbelief over her father’s sense of entitlement, while others sympathized with the complicated emotions surrounding familial obligation. A few suggested that it might be worth considering the totality of the situation before making a decision, while many stood firmly behind her choice not to engage with her father.
Others pointed out that the request itself is a reflection of deeper issues, showing how the dynamics of toxic relationships can resurface in unexpected ways. The notion that her father could casually ask for a life-altering gift after years of harm left many commenters shaking their heads. One user sarcastically remarked on the absurdity of such a demand, wondering how someone could feel justified in making such a request from a victim of their own actions.
As this discussion unfolded, it became clear that the complexity of family ties can lead to unexpected situations, especially when past trauma is involved. Some participants emphasized that her health and well-being should come first, arguing that no one should feel pressured to sacrifice for someone who had repeatedly let them down.
Ultimately, this story raises a complicated question about what family loyalty should look like, especially in the face of prior abuse. How does one navigate the demands of a parent who has caused so much pain? As this parent moves forward, many wonder about the boundaries that one should establish when faced with such conflicting emotions and expectations.
More from Decluttering Mom: