A red crate holding folded blue cloth, like donated secondhand clothing

Goodwill Has Its Best Year In Nearly 125 Years With More Than $7 Billion In Retail Sales, Yet Shoppers Call It Greedwill And One Big Regional Group Lost More Than $22 Million

Goodwill had the best year in its nearly 125-year history. The nonprofit says it surpassed $7 billion in retail sales in 2025, and at the same time some shoppers are grumbling about prices and nicknaming it “Greedwill.”

A red crate holding folded blue cloth, like donated secondhand clothing

The tension is the subject of a commentary video from the YouTube channel Savannah Savannah. It cites a used duvet cover priced at $49.99, a big regional operation that lost more than $22 million, and the use of artificial intelligence to price donated goods.

The numbers behind those claims tell a more layered story than either the cheerful headlines or the angry comments.

“2025 Was The Best Year In Our History” Says Goodwill’s Chief Operating Officer

Goodwill Industries International says it passed $7 billion in revenue in 2025, a record, from roughly 3,400 stores in the U.S. and Canada. That is up about 7 percent from the year before, according to a January 26, 2026 national business report.

Chief operating officer David Eagles put it this way: “2025 was the best year in our history, and we’re [almost] 125 years old. We have seen record revenues, record donations, record store transactions and, for us, what’s most exciting, record margin dollars.”

He explained that “margin” means money for the mission, which he described as supporting 2 million people a year and helping about 130,000 of them into sustainable careers.

He gave other figures too: nearly 120 million donation counts and nearly 300 million shopping transactions. The online marketplace ShopGoodwill.com reached $450 million in gross merchandise value, also its best year.

Shoppers Want $5 T-Shirts And $15 Jeans

Sales are up nearly 50 percent from 2019, according to a business magazine summary. Goodwill plans roughly 50 to 100 new stores in 2026.

Reports link the growth to shoppers hunting for value, including $5 T-shirts and $15 jeans. Younger shoppers also see secondhand as stylish and sustainable, and Eagles says over two-thirds of Gen Z and millennials bought some secondhand clothing last year.

Chief executive Steven C. Preston says the business holds up in any economy. “We are pretty steady in almost any economic situation. But when things are tight, we’re probably more likely to get that foot traffic.”

Goodwill is not alone. Savers Value Village posted a nearly 16 percent jump in net sales, and ThredUp grew revenue 34 percent.

Why Some Shoppers Call It “Greedwill”

Alongside the boom came the complaints. Some shoppers have blasted prices, and the nickname “Greedwill” has been attached to things like a “donation roundup” request at the register. An expert quoted in January coverage said the “mission is slipping.”

The $49.99 duvet cover in the video is one item at one store, so it says little about what the chain charges overall. The “Greedwill” label is a nickname shoppers use, not a finding by any auditor.

One fact helps explain the gap between the record and the complaints. Goodwill is a federation of more than 150 independent local organizations that sell donated goods and use the revenue for job training and career services, so the $7 billion is a combined figure and local finances vary widely.

Evergreen Goodwill In Seattle Has Lost More Than $22 Million

One of the biggest local operations is struggling. Evergreen Goodwill, which runs stores around Seattle, has lost more than $22 million in recent years, according to a September 2026 Seattle newspaper report.

Tax records cited by the paper show a $9.3 million loss in the year ending June 2025 and a $12.3 million loss in the year ending June 2020. The nonprofit has about 2,000 employees and 22 stores in Western Washington.

The problem is labor costs. Washington’s and Seattle’s minimum wage has nearly doubled in a decade, while the group’s revenue grew about 45 percent.

CEO Libby Johnson McKee, a former Amazon executive who took over in 2024, says the business has to change. “We have to do this business in a less manual way to move forward.” She expects to reach profitability in “the next one to two years.”

Three Job Training Centers Closed And 29 Workers Were Laid Off

In July 2026 the organization closed three of its five job-training centers, in Bellingham, Mount Vernon and Bremerton. It laid off 29 workers, about half of its job training and education programming staff.

Spokesperson Alyssa Grigg said the pause was a “restructuring of our entire program offering” in response to changes in the job market, including artificial intelligence and more employers requiring credentials. She said the remaining Seattle and Everett centers serve 70 percent of students, and remote learning is available elsewhere.

“Our intention is not to abandon those communities,” Grigg said. One anonymous employee told the paper that morale on the mission side was “at rock bottom.”

An AI Priced A Cable At $12 And A Worker Changed It To $3

Evergreen Goodwill is also testing an AI model that scans an item and suggests a price. The Seattle paper described a worker scanning a white cable that the model priced at $12.

The worker thought that was too high and set the price at $3 so the model could learn. McKee says the tool can price items higher or lower and could save labor costs, and she argues those savings will fund more training.

Another Goodwill, in Central Texas, has also used AI in pricing, according to a trade outlet.

How To Shop Goodwill Smarter

The record year does not mean every store is cashing in, so judge your local store by what it charges and what it does with the money. Compare prices on similar items at nearby thrift shops, and remember that tags vary from one location to the next.

If a checkout request for a round-up donation bothers you, you can say no. And if you want your dollars to support job training, ask the store which programs your local Goodwill runs.

The bigger picture is that the national brand is booming while a labor-heavy local branch is struggling. The cost of that squeeze, as Seattle shows, is landing on job training, which is the reason Goodwill exists.

More Stories You May Like