A pregnant woman’s decision not to tell her estranged father about the baby has drawn thousands of responses on Reddit, reigniting a debate that family therapists say they encounter constantly: when an adult child cuts off a parent who abandoned them or enabled abuse, does a grandchild change the equation?
In her case, the answer is no. And according to researchers who study family estrangement, she is far from alone.
What happened: abandonment, abuse, and a pregnancy kept secret
The woman, posting anonymously in Reddit’s AITAH forum, described a father who left during her childhood, was absent while abuse occurred in the home, and later resurfaced not with an apology but with postcards that minimized her experience and centered his own hurt feelings. Now pregnant, she has decided he will not learn about the child at all.
“You owe this person absolutely nothing,” read the top-voted reply, urging her to “stop letting him live rent free” in her head. The overwhelming consensus among commenters was that she was right to withhold the news, not as punishment, but as protection.
The post is one data point, but the pattern it represents is well documented. Karl Pillemer, a Cornell University sociologist and author of Fault Lines: Fractured Families and How to Mend Them (2020), found in a nationally representative survey that roughly 27 percent of Americans are estranged from a close family member. Among those who cut contact with a parent, unresolved abuse or neglect was one of the most frequently cited reasons.
Pregnancy as a boundary, not a bridge
Therapists who specialize in estrangement say pregnancy is one of the most common pressure points. Well-meaning relatives, friends, and even strangers often urge reconciliation once a baby is on the way, framing grandparenthood as a reset button.
But for adults who experienced childhood harm, the opposite instinct tends to kick in. Becoming a parent can sharpen awareness of what was endured and strengthen the resolve not to repeat it. The woman in the Reddit post described her decision in exactly those terms: keeping her father away from the baby was not revenge but a refusal to let a cycle of harm reach the next generation.
Joshua Coleman, a psychologist and author of Rules of Estrangement (2021), has noted that adult children who set these boundaries often report feeling more empowered as new parents precisely because they are making the protective choices their own parents failed to make. Even Coleman, who advocates for reconciliation when possible, acknowledges that contact should not be restored without genuine accountability from the estranging parent.
That accountability is what many commenters across similar Reddit threads say is missing. In a separate thread about a daughter who told her father never to contact her again, one commenter wrote that they “really need to hear the mom’s explanation for doing this,” highlighting how unanswered questions about parental complicity can fester for decades. Without that explanation, milestones like pregnancy become moments to reinforce a boundary rather than lower one.
The legal landscape: grandparent rights vary widely
One dimension often missing from these online debates is the legal one. In the United States, all 50 states have some form of grandparent visitation statute, though the strength and scope vary dramatically. The U.S. Supreme Court’s 2000 decision in Troxel v. Granville established that fit parents have a fundamental right to make decisions about who has access to their children, setting a high bar for grandparents seeking court-ordered visitation.
In practice, this means a grandparent who was absent or complicit in abuse would face significant legal hurdles in most jurisdictions. But the statutes exist, and estranged parents do sometimes pursue them. Family law attorneys generally advise adults in situations like the one described in the Reddit post to document the history of estrangement and, if necessary, consult a lawyer before the baby arrives.
Why “NTA” carries real weight for survivors
The internet shorthand “NTA” (not the antagonist) may look trivial, but for people who grew up being told they were selfish for resisting harmful family dynamics, community validation can be meaningful. Research on online support communities, including a 2022 study published in Computers in Human Behavior, has found that peer affirmation in moderated forums can reduce feelings of isolation and guilt among adults processing family trauma.
In a related AITAH thread, a woman who blocked her mother after refusing to share her father’s address was told, “Blocking her was the healthiest move you’ve made.” In another discussion, commenters urged a woman not to sacrifice her well-being to manage her father’s new wife’s pregnancy, calling it “not your responsibility.”
These verdicts are not therapy. But they reflect a generational recalibration of what family obligation means when the family in question caused harm. The old script said you forgive because they’re blood. The emerging one says you protect yourself first, and forgiveness, if it comes at all, requires the other person to do real work.
What therapists recommend
Clinicians who work with estranged families generally agree on a few principles that apply directly to situations like this one:
- Boundaries are not punishment. Limiting or ending contact with a parent who caused harm is a protective measure, not an act of cruelty. The American Psychological Association’s guidelines on trauma recovery emphasize that survivors have the right to control who is in their lives.
- A new baby does not erase old harm. Pregnancy can intensify unresolved grief and trauma. Therapists caution against using a grandchild as a reconciliation tool, because it places the emotional burden on the new parent at a vulnerable time.
- Accountability must come first. If an estranged parent wants to re-enter their adult child’s life, most therapists say the parent needs to acknowledge the specific harm, take responsibility without deflecting, and demonstrate sustained change over time, not just send postcards.
For the woman in the Reddit post, her father has done none of those things. His messages center his own feelings, not her experience. Until that changes, her decision to keep the pregnancy private is, by most clinical standards, a reasonable one.
More from Decluttering Mom: