A Thanksgiving table set with white candles, evoking a budget holiday dinner for the family.

Mom Aimed For $20 But Fed A Whole Thanksgiving Dinner For $21.88 At Dollar Tree With No Pantry Items, Improvising Canned Chicken Because There Was No Turkey

Feeding a family a full Thanksgiving dinner for about the price of two fast food combos sounds like a stunt. One mom decided to try it, with a self imposed rule that made it harder: no help from the pantry at all.

A Thanksgiving table set with white candles, evoking a budget holiday dinner for the family.

According to SouthernFrugalMomma, she shopped only at Dollar Tree and kept her budget “around $20.” The only things she used from home were salt, pepper and water.

Her total at the register came to $21.88. She says the store is so quiet she feels like she has to whisper, and she wandered the aisles wondering if she wanted mac and cheese or a pasta salad.

The $21.88 Receipt: Frozen Broccoli, Canned Yams And Velveeta Sauce

She walked through every price. Frozen broccoli florets were $1.25 and a pepper stir fry mix was a clearance find at $0.63, while a stuffing mix cost $1.50 and shelf stable milk was $1.25.

Two cans of white chicken were $1.25 apiece, pecans were $1.25, and all purpose flour was $1.50. Two cans of yams were $1.50 each, and she also grabbed butter on clearance.

The rest of the cart included Velveeta cheese sauce at $1.25, apple pie filling at $1.25, French style green beans at $1.50, salted crackers at $1.25 and a macaroni and cheese dinner at $1.50.

She noticed the milk had a price swing, too. It had been $1.50, but the sign said $1.25, and “that is what it rang up, and I was like, heck yes.”

“They Had No Turkey,” So Canned Chicken Became The Main Dish

Normally, she says, you would want a turkey or a ham for Thanksgiving. The store did not have turkey, and she says it once sold canned turkey and gravy but no longer does, at least not at the location near her.

So she improvised. She melted butter, whisked in two tablespoons of flour to make a roux, then added a pint jar of milk mixed with the broth drained from the chicken.

Once it thickened like gravy, she seasoned it with two pinches of salt and one big pinch of pepper and stirred in both cans of chicken. She poured it into a casserole dish and topped it with stuffing made with 2 1/4 cups of water, skipping the butter the box calls for to save it for other dishes.

The result she calls a chicken gravy stuffing casserole, baked at 350 until bubbly.

Five Mini Apple Pies Baked In A Jumbo Muffin Pan

She started with dessert. Using a jumbo muffin pan, she cut half a stick of butter into 1 1/4 cups of flour and added four tablespoons of ice cold water for the crust.

The dough made five little pies. She pre-baked the shells at 400, filled them with the apple filling and topped each with a lattice made from the leftover crust.

“Perfect. I did it,” she says, and she returned them to the oven until golden brown. She says she could have made more but did not want to overdo it.

Four Sides That Cost Pennies, From Smothered Green Beans To Sweet Potato Casserole

For the first side she chopped part of the pepper stir fry mix and sauteed it with a tablespoon of butter and thin sliced ham, then added the juice from the green beans to deglaze the pot. The result is smothered green beans, seasoned only with salt and pepper.

The sweet potato casserole came from two cans of yams. She boiled the syrup down until thick, mashed the yams with butter, milk, salt and pepper, and topped them with a streusel of crushed pecans, flour, butter and that syrup.

It baked at 375 for about 25 minutes. For the broccoli casserole she made a homemade cheese sauce with butter, flour, a cup of milk and half the Velveeta packet, and mixed in thawed broccoli and sauteed peppers.

She topped it with buttered cracker crumbs and baked it at 375 for about 20 minutes. The last side was basic mac and cheese, because “in this house, we always have to have a mac and cheese with Thanksgiving dinner. It’s just a rule.”

“Can You Tell It Came From The Dollar Tree?” “Not Really”

When it was time to eat, she plated up the chicken casserole, the broccoli casserole, the green beans, the mac and cheese, the sweet potatoes and a mini pie. She asked her family if they could tell it came from the Dollar Tree, and one answered, “Not really.”

Her son Braden skipped the sweet potato casserole because, she says, he hates sweet potatoes, though she insists “they’re delicious.” Another family member tried the apple pies and called them delicious.

She was the toughest critic. She calls the chicken casserole “probably better than any casserole I’ve ever made” and says the sweet potato casserole is her favorite thing on the table at Thanksgiving.

Her verdict: “10 out of 10, would make it again.” She also had leftovers, with about a cup of milk, over half a bag of flour, a third of the pepper mix and two sleeves of crackers still on hand.

How To Stretch A Dollar Tree Thanksgiving Budget Of $20

You can borrow her method even if you shop at a different store. The tricks are mostly about using one ingredient in several dishes.

  • Buy a few base items, such as flour, butter and milk, and use them for the gravy, the cheese sauce and the pie crust.
  • Save the liquid from cans. Chicken broth became gravy and green bean juice flavored the sides.
  • Check clearance first. Her $0.63 pepper mix and discounted butter helped keep the total near $20.
  • Compare prices between stores. She says milk was $1.25 at two of her four Dollar Trees and $1.50 at the other two.
  • Do not expect a turkey. Canned chicken works as a main dish when you swap in a gravy and a stuffing topping.

A real Thanksgiving table for $21.88 shows that a good meal comes from planning, not a big budget. As she puts it, “You guys can do it too if you try this.”

More Stories You May Like