One mom was caught off guard when her 22-month-old daughter suddenly transformed from an independent sleeper into a child who could no longer rest alone. What began as a temporary measure to comfort a sick toddler turned into a dependency that left the parent scratching her head, unsure of how to reclaim the peaceful nights they once enjoyed. Here is the original Reddit discussion.
The little girl was never one to co-sleep. From a young age, she stuck to a solid sleep routine, drifting off to dreamland in her own crib and sleeping through the night without fuss. Even when she transitioned to a toddler bed at 17 months, things remained smooth sailing. She would fall asleep within half an hour and keep it going for 10 to 12 hours. That was until she caught a bug from daycare, and everything changed.
On a particularly rough night, the mom decided to stay in her daughter’s bed to help her feel better. The sick toddler needed comfort, and the parent was happy to provide it. However, this one night of shared sleep led to a new and unexpected challenge. Since that night, the little girl refused to fall asleep unless one of her parents was there beside her. It wasn’t just a moment of needing reassurance; now, if left alone, she would wake up crying in the middle of the night, demanding the presence of one of her parents.
Even after the parent tried to return to their previous sleep routine, the toddler’s cries would echo through the night. Several attempts were made to explain that she could sleep on her own and that her parents were just down the hallway. Yet, the girl wouldn’t have it. Instead, she would tug at her parent’s hand, insisting they join her in her room. The parental efforts to restore her independence seemed futile.
In a bid to rectify this new sleeping arrangement, the parent considered the “extinction” method, an approach that involves letting the child cry it out. However, listening to her daughter sob for 30 minutes straight was tough. With boogers covering her little face and the sound of distress filling the air, it became a difficult decision to leave her alone. As time passed, the parent was left questioning whether to stick to their plan or accept that the co-dependency was simply part of parenting a toddler.
People had very different reactions to the mom’s post. Some thought it might be best to double down on extinction, suggesting consistency could eventually reintroduce the idea of independent sleep. They pointed out that toddlers often go through phases, and with a little persistence, she might find her way back to sleeping solo.
Others had different insights, reminding the parent that this kind of behavior isn’t unusual and, at times, is just part of growing up. They reflected on their own experiences, sharing that many little ones go through similar phases of attachment, especially after a period of illness or stress. It’s quite normal for a child to seek comfort when they are feeling vulnerable.
Many parents chimed in, offering a variety of approaches, whether it was modifying the bedtime routine or introducing a comfort object to help the toddler feel more secure. A few suggested creating a calming environment with comforting sounds or soft lights that might ease the transition back to independent sleeping.
However, not everyone was keen on the idea of rigorous sleep training. Some felt that parenting is often about rolling with the punches and adapting to what kids need at different stages. The conversation highlighted the balance between fostering independence and meeting a child’s need for security during challenging times.
As the discussion played out, it became clear that there was no one-size-fits-all solution. The relentless cycle of waking and crying created a somewhat exhausting loop for the mom. Each suggestion brought its own set of challenges and potential outcomes, leaving her to weigh what might work best for her family.
In the end, the question remained open: How does one navigate this new reality of nighttime co-dependence without losing sight of the independence the toddler once had? With so many opinions and personal experiences on the table, it’s evident that every child has a unique journey when it comes to sleep.
More from Decluttering Mom: