A gold fountain pen resting on a desk

Reseller Says Vintage Pens Are A Hidden Ebay Category With 15,000 Schaeffer Listings And Over 5,000 Sold In 90 Days, Often Costing Nothing At Estate Sales

If you ever cleaned out a relative’s desk drawer, you may have been holding a small pile of cash. One reseller says vintage pens are a hidden category on eBay that has quietly paid bills for decades.

A gold fountain pen resting on a desk

She is the voice behind the Flipping High Gram channel, and she says that if she had to sell only one category, she would choose vintage pens and pencils over vintage Japan items, purses or jewelry. Her proof is one brand: she says there are 15,000 listings for vintage Schaeffer pens on eBay, and in the last 90 days over 5,000 of them have sold.

Four Reasons She Would Pick Pens Over Almost Anything

First, they are tiny. A shoebox can hold hundreds, and a small set of drawers can hold an entire inventory, so there is no digging through bins for one sold item.

Second, they are light. Most pens ship in a small box and weigh almost nothing, so shipping costs stay low.

Third, the cost is often zero. At estate sales and yard sales the pens in the drawer are an afterthought. She says to ask about them at checkout, because families often say, “Just take it.” Even when there is a price, it is usually a couple of dollars for the whole box.

Fourth, pen collectors are enthusiastic. Many own hundreds or thousands of pens, and they pay up. A seller who specializes can build a base of repeat customers.

A Broken Pen Is Not Trash To A Collector

Here is the bonus most resellers miss. Many collectors like to restore pens, so a pen with a dried-out ink reservoir or a scratched barrel is a project, not junk. Some collectors even prefer pens that need work, because restoring them is fun and the price is better than a perfect one.

She also says you can sell parts. A single fountain pen nib sold for $150, and caps, clips and bodies all have buyers who are hunting for a match.

The Brands To Look For

She says the brands she runs into most are Cross, Schaeffer and Waterman, along with Montblanc, Parker, Pilot, Pelikan and Lamy.

Cross is the pen your grandfather may have received as a retirement gift. They are thin metal ballpoints or mechanical pencils, often in matched sets. Look for gold-filled, solid gold or sterling versions, and check the band or cap for stamps like 14K, 10K or sterling.

Schaeffer, which is properly spelled Sheaffer, is the brand with the 15,000 listings. She says sellers misspell it in titles all the time, so double check your spelling. Look for the little white dot on the cap or clip, which marked the better lifetime models, and watch for the Snorkel and Touchdown models with their filling systems.

Waterman pens in early hard rubber or celluloid are sought after. Parker’s 51 is, in her words, one of the holy grails of collecting. Montblanc is recognizable by the white star on the cap. Pilot, a Japanese brand, is known for the Namiki lacquer designs and the retractable Vanishing Point.

How To Sort A Drawer Of 300 Pens

Her system starts with grabbing a box. If the whole lot is cheap, she goes right to checkout, and if she has to pay she sorts it on the spot.

She removes the dime-a-dozen wood school pencils and cheap plastic hotel and bank pens first. The exception is vintage advertising pens with company names, which appeal to advertising collectors.

Then she pulls every fountain pen. Any pen with a metal nib goes in the keeper pile, no matter how beat up. Next come mechanical pencils with some weight, since they often match a pen and can complete a set.

Under a light she reads the cap, clip and bands for stamps such as 14K, 10K, gold-filled and sterling. She also keeps boxes and paperwork, because empty boxes sell on their own.

Seven Mistakes That Can Cost You

Fakes are the first. Montblanc is one of the most counterfeited pens in the world. She says to check for a serial number, look for sharp, clean engraving on the nib, and examine the weight and the quality of the star. If you are not sure, say so in the listing.

Do not fill an old pen with ink to test it. List it as untested.

Do not soak old pens or clean them with alcohol or harsh chemicals, and never use hot water. Many vintage pens are celluloid or hard rubber, which harsh cleaning can destroy. She admits she once used a Q-tip with rubbing alcohol and says she knows better now.

Look closely at condition. Check for cracks near the cap, dents, bent nibs, missing clips and brassing, where gold plating has worn off. None of these stop a sale, but they need to be in the photos and the description.

Photograph the pen in natural light or a light box, because collectors notice every shade difference.

Read gold markings exactly as stamped. Gold-filled is not solid gold.

And do not throw away anything you think is wrecked. She has sold some very rough pens for an easy $100.

Photos, Titles And Pricing That Work

For photos she takes the whole pen capped and uncapped, plus close-ups of the front and back of the nib, and shows every flaw. Collectors who do not see the right close-ups will ignore a listing or ask for better photos.

For titles, she leads with the brand, then the model, color and key details. Her example is a Schaeffer white dot fountain pen with a 14k nib, green striped, for restoration. Words like 14k, sterling and for parts or repair help buyers find it.

If you are unsure about price when starting out, she suggests seven day auctions, with a minimum bid you would be happy with if only one person bids.

She ships old pens in a box, not a bubble mailer, wrapping any original box in a plastic sleeve and bubble wrap first.

Pencils, Refills And Other Small Wins

Old wood pencils can also be valuable. She names Eberhard Faber and American Pencil Company, especially the Venus line, as the sought-after makers. Original Blackwing pencils were made by Eberhard Faber, and collectors hunt for those.

Leads and ink refills found in old tins sell constantly. She keeps them in a box until she has enough for a lot.

What To Look For In That Next Drawer

Next time you open a desk drawer at an estate sale, look for a metal nib, a white dot or a 14K stamp. Ask the price of the whole box, and take a close look before you donate or toss a drawer of pens at home. Many of them are tiny, light and cost almost nothing, which is why she calls this one of the best hidden categories on eBay.

More Stories You May Like