The story sounds like something cooked up in a writers’ room: a woman who finally lets herself love again after losing a partner, only to have her new fiancé die on their wedding day. Then comes an even darker twist, when she learns he had been living a secret life. For Kaitlin Palmieri, a 35-year-old from New York, that plotline is not a script but the shape of her twenties and early thirties.
Her first love, Mike, died suddenly on her 30th birthday, and the grief nearly took her with him. Years later, when she met Eric and they started planning a future together, it felt like proof that life could still surprise her in good ways. Instead, the shocks kept coming, and in the worst possible order.
The woman who kept losing the love of her life
Before anyone had heard of her, Kaitlin Palmieri was just a young woman in New York who thought she had her life roughly mapped out. She was in love with Mike, the kind of first serious partner she believed she would grow old with, until he died on her 30th birthday and ripped up that plan in one night. In interviews she has described how that loss left her feeling as if the floor had vanished, and how she spent years trying to function while still emotionally anchored to the moment Mike died, a history she later shared in more detail when she spoke about boyfriend before Eric,.
By the time she met Eric, she was no longer a wide-eyed romantic but someone who knew exactly how much it hurt when a future disappears. That is part of why she let herself lean into the relationship anyway. Eric, who friends and family saw as charming and attentive, stepped into her life as the man who seemed to understand that history and still wanted to build something new with her. They got engaged, planned a wedding, and surrounded themselves with people who had watched her crawl out of one tragedy already. For Kaitlin, it felt like a second chance she had earned the hard way.
The wedding day that turned into a crime scene of the heart
On the day she was meant to marry Eric, Kaitlin woke up expecting nerves about vows and photos, not a medical emergency. Instead, her fiancé collapsed and never made it to the ceremony, a shock that left guests reeling and her standing in a venue that had been decorated for a party that would never happen. In detailed accounts she has given since, she describes the moment as a kind of out-of-body experience, like watching someone else’s life fall apart in slow motion, a feeling echoed by another woman who wrote that she felt trapped in a movie when own fiancé died.
The shock did not end when the guests went home. A post mortem later revealed that Eric had died from a sudden heart attack linked to an undiagnosed heart condition, a medical explanation that did little to soften the emotional blow. Instead of heading off on a honeymoon, she found herself planning a funeral and trying to reconcile the man she loved with the clinical language in the report that described how he. Friends recall that she moved through those early days on autopilot, ticking off logistics while privately wondering how she could possibly survive a second loss of a partner in such a short span of time.
The secret life that rewrote her grief
For a long stretch after Eric’s death, Kaitlin grieved him as the devoted partner she believed he had been. She shared photos, replayed memories, and tried to live with a story in which she had simply been catastrophically unlucky in love. That version of events shattered when she came across an Instagram tribute that mentioned a man with the same name as her fiancé and details that did not line up with the life she knew. Curiosity quickly turned to dread as she clicked through, then messaged the woman behind the post, and eventually realised that Eric had been cheating on her, a discovery that has been described as finding out her fiancé had been living double life even.
The revelation did not just add a footnote to her grief, it rewrote it. She has said it felt like being emotionally trapped with nowhere to run while anger, betrayal, and sadness piled on top of the loss itself, a reaction that mirrors another woman’s account of feeling as if the relationship she had mourned was a fiction once she learned her dead partner had also been unfaithful, something captured in detail when she described years of hidden. Kaitlin has since talked about how she had so much frustration and nowhere to put it, because the one person who could answer for the betrayal was already gone.
More from Decluttering Mom: