Store brands used to be the boring cousins of the grocery aisle, but shoppers have figured out that the right private label can taste suspiciously like the big-name stuff. Few mysteries get people talking quite like the question of who actually makes Walmart’s Great Value butter. The rumor mill has zeroed in on one familiar dairy giant, and the trail of photos, packaging quirks, and industry clues is surprisingly compelling, even if nothing is officially nailed down.
At the center of the chatter is the idea that Great Value sticks might roll off the same lines as a major national brand, only to land in a cheaper wrapper. Fans who swear by the flavor are convinced they are getting name-brand quality at a discount, and they have receipts in the form of viral posts and side-by-side comparisons. The result is a kind of crowdsourced detective story that says as much about how modern food supply chains work as it does about what ends up on toast.
Why Land O’Lakes keeps coming up in the butter rumor mill
The leading theory points straight at Land O’Lakes as the quiet force behind Walmart’s house-brand butter. Shoppers have shared photos and anecdotes of Great Value sticks that look and taste so similar to Land O’Lakes that they are convinced the two are twins separated at the packaging line. One viral post flatly claimed that Land O’Lakes is the brand rumored to be behind Walmart’s Great Value butter, framing the connection as an open secret rather than a wild guess.
Some of the most eyebrow-raising evidence comes from shoppers who say they have literally peeled back the curtain. More than one customer has reported finding Great Value butter sticks tucked inside what appears to be a Land O’Lakes box, suggesting a packaging mix-up that hints at a shared production line. In a Facebook baking group, one commenter thanked another member for pointing out that when they buy Great Value butter from Walmart they might actually be buying Land O Lakes, with the note framed as a grateful “Thank you” for the tip. None of this counts as a signed contract, but it has been enough to convince a lot of home bakers that the budget-friendly sticks in their fridge have premium roots.
How Walmart’s private-label playbook fuels the speculation
Part of why the Land O’Lakes theory feels plausible is that Walmart already leans heavily on big-name manufacturers to fill out its Great Value lineup. The retailer’s own site showcases how sprawling the Walmart grocery operation is, and reporting on its private-label strategy notes that the company outsources from multiple suppliers to keep shelves stocked. Analysts have pointed out that Walmart outsources production for Great Value to several different companies, a setup that lets it negotiate prices while still delivering consistent products, even if the exact partners are not officially confirmed.
That pattern shows up across the store. A breakdown of Companies Behind Walmart Great Value Brand Products notes that many items are quietly produced by well-known manufacturers that also sell under their own labels. Another list of Land Lakes Dairy connections goes further, explicitly naming Land O’Lakes as a company believed to handle dairy products for Walmart’s value line. Put together, these snapshots of the supply chain make it easy for shoppers to believe that the butter in a Great Value wrapper is not some mystery formula, but a familiar brand in store-brand clothing.
The social media sleuths, the ConAgra curveball, and what remains unverified
The rumor around Great Value butter did not grow in a vacuum, it is part of a broader wave of online detective work around store-brand dairy. Earlier this year, coverage of why shoppers suspect the butter from Aldi, Costco, Trader Joe’s, Kroger, and Food Lion might share a common source pointed out that if a single supplier is filling multiple private-label orders, then those suspicions would, at least technically, be correct. That analysis of why shoppers suspect overlapping butter suppliers helped normalize the idea that one big dairy name could be quietly churning out sticks for a whole roster of retailers.
At the same time, the reporting is careful to note the limits of this kind of crowdsourced evidence. There is no way to confirm the integrity of every photo posted on social media, and investigators have stressed that while images of lookalike butter wrappers are intriguing, they are not proof on their own. That caution surfaced again in coverage that reminded readers there is no guaranteed way to verify every viral claim about packaging crossovers at chains like Aldi, Costco, Trader Joe’s, Kroger, and Food Lion in 2019, even if the patterns look convincing.
Into that already murky picture comes another twist: some analysts have floated ConAgra Brands as a possible player in Walmart’s butter story. One report noted that Another possible supplier of Walmart Great Value butter is ConAgra Brands, a major food company with the scale to handle large private-label contracts. That theory sits alongside the Land O’Lakes rumor rather than replacing it, reinforcing the idea that Walmart could be splitting production among several partners to hedge against shortages and regional demand.
More from Decluttering Mom: