Assorted-color Car Toys

11 Rare Toys From the ’90s Now Worth Hundreds

If you’re a ’90s kid, there’s a good chance that your old toys are not just lying in your attic, gathering dust. Some of those relics from your childhood could actually be worth hundreds, or even thousands, of dollars today.

The 1990s were a golden era for toys, with a plethora of colourful, unique, and innovative products hitting the shelves. Today, many of these toys have become highly sought after collectibles. Here are 11 rare toys from the ’90s that are now worth hundreds.

1. First Edition Pokémon Cards

Holographic Charizard Pokémon card in protective case displayed on wooden surface with other Charizard cards visible underneath
Image Credit: Erik Mclean/Pexels.

Who could have predicted that those colourful Pokémon cards you traded with friends would be worth so much today? A first edition holographic Charizard, for instance, can fetch thousands of dollars. Even less rare cards, like a first edition Pikachu, can be worth hundreds if they’re in good condition.

2. Original Furby

Furby McDonalds toys
Image Credit: Zinck Ink/eBay.

Furbies were a must-have toy in the late ’90s. Today, an original 1998 Furby in its original packaging can fetch a hefty sum. Depending on the model and condition, some Furbies are worth hundreds of dollars to collectors.

3. Beanie Babies

Halloween-Themed Beanie Babies
Image Credit: Automotive Parts Connection / Ebay

Beanie Babies were a massive craze in the ’90s, with children and adults alike collecting these small stuffed animals. Today, certain rare Beanie Babies, such as the Princess Diana Bear, can sell for hundreds or even thousands of dollars.

4. Polly Pocket Sets

Colorful Polly Pocket miniature playsets opened on a carpet, revealing tiny rooms, furniture, and characters
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Polly Pocket sets, with their tiny dolls and intricate playsets, were a hit among young girls in the ’90s. Today, these sets, especially the vintage ones in good condition, can fetch hundreds of dollars on the collector’s market.

5. Power Rangers Action Figures

Burger King's 1994 Mighty Morphin Power Rangers Toys
Image Credit: ad11ht / Ebay

Power Rangers was one of the biggest TV franchises of the ’90s, and the toys were just as popular. Original Power Rangers action figures, particularly the ones still in their packaging, can be worth a substantial amount today.

6. LEGO Sets

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

While LEGO has been around for decades, certain sets from the ’90s, such as the Star Wars or Harry Potter series, can be worth hundreds, especially if they’re unopened.

7. American Girl Dolls

Brunette American Girl doll in a pink skirt, white graphic tee, matching pink beret, and grey ankle boots, standing on a display stand
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

American Girl Dolls have been beloved by children for generations, but certain discontinued dolls from the ’90s, like the original Samantha, Molly, and Kirsten dolls, can fetch a high price on the collector’s market nowadays.

8. Super Soaker CPS 2000

Nerf Super Soaker XP50-AP, yellow and green water gun, in colorful packaging, designed for ages 6 and up
Image credit: Prairie Dog Treasures/eBay.

The Super Soaker CPS 2000 was the most powerful water gun of its time when it was released in the ’90s. Today, this classic summer toy, especially if it’s still in its original packaging, can be worth hundreds of dollars.

9. Tamagotchi

Translucent yellow Tamagotchi virtual pet toy with small screen, white buttons, and metal ball chain keychain
Image Credit: Museum Rotterdam – Public Domain/Wiki Commons.

The original virtual pet, Tamagotchis were a global sensation in the ’90s. These digital pets can be worth a decent amount today, especially the original models in good condition or still in their packaging.

10. Sega Genesis Console

Sega Genesis console with two black controllers, eight classic game cartridges arranged around the system, placed on a wooden floor, retro gaming setup, nostalgic video game collection
Image credit: ebay.

Sega Genesis was one of the leading consoles in the ’90s. A console in good condition, preferably with games and original controllers, can sell for a high price on the collector’s market.

11. Magic: The Gathering Cards

Stack of early Magic: The Gathering trading cards spread out on a black surface, with "Harbor Guardian" card on top
Image Credit: Cdimaria190/eBay.

Although Magic: The Gathering is still popular today, certain cards from the ’90s are highly sought after by collectors. Rare cards like the Black Lotus can be worth hundreds or even thousands of dollars.

If you were a ’90s kid, it might be worth taking a trip down memory lane and rummaging through your old toy box. You never know, you might be sitting on a goldmine. Even if you don’t find a treasure, you’ll have a great time reliving those nostalgic ’90s memories.