Garage sales can feel like a fun way to find new stuff, but sometimes you stumble across items that are actually worth a good amount of money. It’s easy to miss these treasures if you don’t know what to look for.
Knowing the signs that mark an item’s real value can help you spot worthwhile finds instead of just clutter. This guide will help you recognize when something at a garage sale might be more than just a bargain.
Original vintage board games in pristine condition
When you find an original vintage board game, its condition really matters. If the game is complete, with all parts like cards, tokens, and instructions, it’s often worth more.
Look for games from the mid-20th century or earlier, especially those that haven’t been heavily played or damaged.
You’ll want to check the box quality too. A clean, undamaged box can boost the value.
If you spot a rare game with those qualities at a garage sale, it could be worth real money to collectors.
Rare McDonald’s Happy Meal toys from the 1990s
If you find McDonald’s Happy Meal toys from the 1990s, don’t overlook them. Many of these toys, especially those tied to popular series or characters, can be surprisingly valuable.
Toys like Teenie Beanie Babies and McNugget Buddies often sell for much more than their original cost. Condition matters a lot, so sealed or complete sets are the ones that catch the highest prices.
Even plastic prizes from regular Happy Meals can turn into collectibles if they are in good shape. This period’s toys are a great example of how everyday items can turn into treasures over time.
High-quality handmade pottery with unique glazes
You can often spot valuable pottery by its unique glazes and handcrafted nature. Pieces made with drip glazes or other special finishes stand out because each one is slightly different.
Look for pottery that is handmade rather than mass-produced. When you see signatures or markings from known artists, it’s a good sign the piece might be worth more.
Pottery made with safe, lead-free clays and fired at high temperatures tends to last longer and keeps its value. Handmade stoneware or ceramics with attention to detail are often collectible.
First edition or signed books from notable authors
You might find first edition books or those signed by their authors at garage sales. These can be valuable, especially if the author is well-known or the book is a classic.
Look for a number line on the copyright page that includes the number 1—that usually means it’s a true first edition. An autograph on the title page can add extra value.
Even modern books can be worth money if they’re first printings or signed. It pays to check carefully before passing a book by.
