You might have boxes in the attic that suddenly feel a lot more interesting. This article shows five Beanie Babies that have climbed in value recently and explains why their condition, tags, and tiny production quirks can change a dusty toy into serious cash.
Bold the most important sentence: You can discover which five Beanie Babies to check now and what specific details make them worth more.
Stick around to learn what to look for with each piece—condition, tag errors, and rare colorways—and how those details tie to the specific Beanie Babies covered later in the article.
Princess Diana Bear
You probably recognize this purple bear as a tribute released after Princess Diana’s death in 1997. Condition and intact original tags matter most for value, so check your seams, tag errors, and the tush tag date.
Some mint-condition first editions have sold for high prices at auction, but most examples trade for modest sums. If you think yours is special, compare listings on places like eBay and consult a current guide to confirm rarity.
Peanut the Royal Blue Elephant
You might find a rare royal blue Peanut tucked in an attic or box of childhood toys. Produced for only a few months in 1995, the deep blue color and short run make these pieces highly sought after by collectors.
Condition and original tags matter a lot, so keep yours intact if you want top-dollar offers. For more on its history and rarity, see this detailed Royal Blue Peanut guide.
Valentino the Bear
You’ll spot Valentino by his red heart and classic brown nose, a design that made him a favorite in the early ’90s. Condition matters: crisp swing tags and an unwashed plush greatly boost value.
Look for production errors and rare tag variations; those details attract serious collectors. Check current listings carefully before pricing — some claims online are inflated.
For a quick guide on typical variants and known rarities, see more about Valentino the Bear at Beaniepedia.
Claude the Crab
You might already own Claude, the multicolored tie‑dye crab that catches the eye. Most Claude Beanie Babies sell for under $50 in typical condition, so don’t assume instant fortune.
Value rises when tags show rare errors or early production quirks. Check the hang tag and tush tag carefully; those determine whether buyers pay a premium.
See a detailed collector guide for identifying valuable tag errors and typical market prices.
Mystic the Unicorn
You might already own a Mystic the Unicorn and not know it can be valuable. Certain editions — especially those with tag errors, coarse manes, or early production dates — have sold for high prices; check details against listings like this price guide and sold examples.
Inspect your tag, horn color, and mane texture closely. Small differences can change value from a few dollars to hundreds or more.
More from Decluttering Mom: