You know that dusty toolbox in the corner of the garage? The one that hasn’t been opened since the Reagan administration? It might be hiding more than a few rusted screws—some vintage tools are quietly selling for hundreds (or even thousands) online. Collectors and craftsmen alike are snatching up well-made, old-school tools for their quality, history, and undeniable charm.
So before you toss that “junk” in your next yard sale, take a closer look. These six old tools could turn your forgotten hardware into a surprising payday.
Stanley Hand Planes
When it comes to collectible tools, Stanley is the gold standard. The company produced hundreds of hand plane models, and early versions from the late 1800s through mid-1900s are now in high demand. Models like the Stanley No. 1, No. 2, and No. 45 combination plane can sell for several hundred dollars—or more if they’re in great shape.
Collectors look for crisp maker’s marks, original knobs, and minimal rust. Even common models can bring in good money if they’re complete and functional. If you find one sitting on a shelf, don’t dismiss it—it might be the smoothest investment you’ll ever make.
Disston Hand Saws
Back when craftsmanship mattered more than mass production, Disston saws were the pride of American workshops. These saws, often featuring beautifully etched blades and polished wooden handles, are highly collectible today. Early Disston models with detailed engravings or medallions on the handle can fetch hundreds.
Even worn examples hold value as decorative pieces for vintage tool lovers or rustic interiors. Look for clear maker’s marks and unique handle shapes. That old saw might not be cutting wood anymore, but it could still cut a nice check.
Snap-On Wrenches
Snap-On tools have always been a status symbol in the garage—and vintage sets are now highly collectible. Early models from the 1930s through 1950s, stamped with the original Snap-On logo, are particularly valuable. Complete wrench sets in their metal boxes can sell for hundreds to collectors and mechanics alike.
Even single wrenches with the right markings can bring in surprising sums. The quality and precision of these old tools make them as functional today as they were 70 years ago. If your granddad left behind a set, it’s worth far more than sentimental value.
Monkey Wrenches
The classic monkey wrench might look simple, but collectors love its industrial appeal. These heavy, adjustable wrenches were common in the early 1900s and came in all shapes and sizes. Older models with wooden handles, stamped logos, or patent dates are especially desirable.
They’ve also become popular with decorators who use them as rustic accent pieces. Depending on age and condition, some can sell for $100 or more. It’s proof that not everything from the toolbox belongs in the junk pile.
Vintage Toolboxes
That old metal toolbox might be worth more than the tools inside it. Early steel or aluminum toolboxes, especially from brands like Kennedy or Craftsman, have become collector favorites for their rugged construction and nostalgic look. Decorators love using them for storage or display.
Boxes with original paint, decals, and trays intact are the most valuable. Even smaller “lunchbox” style cases can bring in solid profits if they’re in good shape. Before you toss it in the scrap bin, give that old box another look—it might be the most stylish storage you own.
Post Drills
Before power tools, there were post drills—hand-cranked machines mounted to walls or beams. These ingenious devices date back to the 1800s and are now prized by collectors for their mechanical beauty. Makers like Champion Blower & Forge or Buffalo Forge are especially sought after.
Even rusty, nonworking examples are valuable for restoration or display. Working models can sell for several hundred dollars or more. So if you spot one lurking in a corner of the garage, don’t let it go—it’s a piece of mechanical history that’s still turning heads.
Old tools tell a story of craftsmanship and durability that’s hard to find today. Whether they’re displayed in a workshop or sold to collectors, these forgotten gadgets are worth more than a trip to the scrap yard. So grab a flashlight and start digging through that garage—you never know what kind of treasure might be hiding under the dust.