You probably have an old toy box or attic stash that feels sentimental — and it might hide something valuable. This article shows which seven types of childhood toys collectors currently pay serious money for, so you can spot potential treasures among your keepsakes.
You’ll get a quick sense of the kinds of items that attract collectors (action figures, trading cards, vintage cars, early electronic games, and iconic dolls) and why condition, rarity, and original packaging matter. Keep this guide handy as you sort through boxes; it will help you decide what to research, photograph, or bring to an appraiser.
1980s Original Transformers Action Figures
If you kept mint-in-box Generation 1 figures, you might be sitting on something collectors want. Condition, original accessories, and unopened packaging drive prices for icons like Optimus Prime and Megatron.
Expect wide price ranges depending on rarity and state of the toy; some listings show values from hundreds to thousands. Check listings and compare sold prices before deciding to sell.
Explore detailed guides and market listings for specific models to confirm authenticity and current demand.
First Edition Pokémon Cards
If you saved first edition Pokémon cards from the late 1990s, you might hold something collectors want. Condition and that tiny “1st Edition” stamp drive prices, so mint cards fetch much higher sums.
You’ll see demand from nostalgia buyers and investors alike, especially for iconic cards like base set Charizard. Learn grading basics and check recent sales before you list to set realistic expectations.
Vintage Hot Wheels Redline Cars
If you find Hot Wheels with the thin red stripe on the tires, you might be holding a Redline from the late 1960s–1970s.
Collectors value mint-condition Redlines, especially those still in original packaging, and some models command high prices on specialist price guides like the Redline Price Guide.
Check casting details, paint, and wheel variations carefully.
Small differences can change value a lot, so document serials and photos before you sell.
Rare Furby Models from the 1990s
You might find a 1998 Furby in your attic that collectors chase, especially limited editions and promo variants.
Some rare pieces—like contest prizes or prototype runs—sell for thousands when in original box and working condition.
Check recent auction results to gauge value before you sell. For market context and examples of high-selling editions, see the roundup of 90s Furby collectibles and values.
Star Wars Early Kenner Figures
If you grew up with the original Kenner line, you know those tiny figures still spark big interest. You can find mint examples selling for far more than their original $1.99 price tag, especially sealed or with rare variants.
Look for original 1977-1980 figures, card backs, and the Early Bird promotion pieces; condition and packaging matter most. Collectors track molds, paint errors, and packaging types to judge value, so small details can change a price dramatically.
Check listings and guides before you sell or buy to avoid surprises.
Nintendo Game & Watch Devices
If you kept boxed Game & Watch units, you might have something collectors want. Vintage handhelds can sell for hundreds, and rare boxed editions fetch considerably more when in excellent condition.
Look for original boxes, manuals, and working units; those extras drive value. Condition matters—scratches and missing parts cut prices fast, so inspect yours before listing.
Learn more about why these early Nintendo handhelds attract buyers on this page about rare 80s and 90s toys worth thousands.
Cabbage Patch Kids Dolls from the 80s
If you kept an original Cabbage Patch Kid, you might have something collectors want. Early dolls, especially those with original outfits, adoption papers, or Xavier Roberts signatures, often fetch higher prices.
Condition matters: mint examples with tags sell best, while play-worn dolls drop in value. Some rare editions and limited releases can bring serious interest from buyers on sites like eBay and in collector forums.
More from Decluttering Mom: