You probably have boxes, shelves, or a closet full of things that once felt priceless — toys, trinkets, and shelfware that marked milestones or fueled hobbies. This article shows which seven familiar collectibles have fallen out of favor and why you might want to make space or cash them in.
Expect practical reasons for the shift—changing tastes, market saturation, and usefulness—and quick tips to decide what to keep, sell, or donate. Keep scrolling if you want a clear sense of what to hold onto and what to let go.
Beanie Babies
You probably remember the thrill of hunting for rare Beanie Babies in the 90s. Many were hyped as future treasures, but most lost value as production ramped up and interest faded.
Some retired or error-tagged Beanie Babies still attract collectors, yet the market is small and prices vary widely. Check a current guide like this list of most sought-after Beanie Babies before assuming yours is worth much.
Decorative collector plates
You probably grew up with a stack of decorative plates in a cabinet that your family treated like mini artworks. Most sell for only a few dollars now, though a few rare limited-edition or signed pieces can fetch more; check listings to know which are worth researching.
If you want to sell, expect slow interest and small prices on auction sites and marketplaces. Handle them gently and photograph any markings so buyers can verify makers and dates.
Trifari costume jewelry
You probably remember Trifari brooches and clip-on earrings from thrift-store runs and aunt’s jewelry boxes.
Once prized for stylish, affordable designs, many pieces now sit unsold because trends moved on and reproductions flooded the market.
If yours has a clear maker’s mark and good condition it can still interest collectors; most everyday Trifari pieces, though, won’t fetch much.
Coro jewelry
You probably remember flashy Coro brooches and duettes that felt timeless in thrift-store bins.
Once prized for rhinestones and bold designs, many pieces lost market value as costume jewelry trends shifted.
You can still find collectible Coro items like early duettes or sterling Corocraft pieces that buyers seek.
Check condition and marks before you sell or toss; some pieces fetch decent prices on sites like Collectors Weekly’s Coro page.
Vintage radios from mid-20th century
You probably remember these warm, wooden consoles sitting in family rooms, their dials glowing softly. They look charming, but many now sit dusty because they’re bulky and need frequent repairs.
If you want one for nostalgia or decor, check collecting guides and identification archives like the Radio Attic’s Archives to verify models and rarity. Restoring tubes and caps takes skill, so expect cost and patience.
Porcelain figurines
You probably remember shelves full of delicate porcelain figurines from past decades. They were once prized as keepsakes and gifts, but many now sit dusty because demand dropped.
Some brands still fetch money with collectors, while most common pieces sell for little. Check markings and condition before deciding what to keep or sell.
If you want to learn more about which lines might hold value, see this guide to vintage figurines that could be hidden on your shelf.
Collectible carnival mementos
You probably remember chalkware figurines, paper tickets, and kitschy souvenirs from fairs and carnivals.
Those items were once prized, but tastes shifted and mass production left many pieces common and hard to sell.
If you inherited a shelf of carnival plates or Kewpie-style figures, expect nostalgia value more than cash.
Online listings and local antique shops often show low demand for these items today; check listings like this roundup of collectibles that lost value to compare.
More from Decluttering Mom:
