Delicious grilled corn skewers served on a cast iron skillet in a rustic cafe setting.

7 Common Kitchen Items That Are Surprisingly Valuable and How to Spot Them Easily

I’ve always been curious about the value of everyday items around my home, especially those in the kitchen. It turns out, some common kitchen tools and accessories can actually be worth more than you might expect. It’s exciting to discover that things you use daily could hold hidden value.

You might be surprised to learn that several familiar kitchen items can be surprisingly valuable to collectors and vintage enthusiasts. Knowing which items to look for can transform how you see your kitchen cupboards and maybe even spark a bit of treasure hunting in your own home.

Close-up of a raw egg yolk in a cast iron skillet, ready for cooking.
Photo by Klaus Nielsen

1950s Pyrex ‘Lucky in Love’ Casserole Dish

I recently learned about the 1959 Pyrex “Lucky in Love” casserole dish, and it really caught my attention. This piece is quite rare, made in a 1-quart size with a pattern featuring green clovers and pink hearts.

What’s interesting is that it might have been a limited release or even a test piece. It doesn’t look flashy, but collectors highly value it, sometimes selling for thousands of dollars. Finding one in good condition feels like striking a small treasure in a kitchen cupboard.

Griswold Cast Iron Skillet

I’ve always been fascinated by Griswold cast iron skillets. These skillets were made in the United States from the late 1800s to mid-1900s and are prized for their quality and durability.

What makes them special is their rare markings and unique sizes. Some rare Griswold pieces can be worth over a thousand dollars, especially if they are in good condition.

Collectors and home cooks both value these skillets. I find it interesting that something so simple can carry such history and value in the kitchen.

Vintage CorningWare Potholder Pattern

I’ve found that vintage CorningWare potholders often feature charming and collectible patterns. One pattern that stands out to me is the iconic Blue Cornflower. It’s simple but recognizable, and many collectors look for it.

The value of these potholders depends a lot on their condition and rarity. Some rare patterns like Spice of Life or Platinum Filigree can be worth more. I always check for any signs of wear before considering a purchase.

Early 20th Century Antique Kitchen Scales

I find early 20th-century kitchen scales really charming. They often have brass dials and sturdy cast-iron bases, which make them both practical and decorative.

Some brands like Detecto, Salter, and Howe are especially sought after by collectors. These scales show craftsmanship that you don’t see in modern versions.

If you have one of these scales, it’s worth checking its condition. Even a well-worn scale can be valuable to the right buyer or add vintage character to a kitchen.

Retro Sunbeam Mixmaster Stand Mixer

I’ve always admired the Sunbeam Mixmaster for its classic design and reliable performance. These mixers, especially models from the mid-1900s, were some of the first electric stand mixers that many families could afford.

What stands out to me is how versatile they were, often coming with attachments like beaters, dough hooks, and sometimes even a juicer or meat grinder. This made them a real workhorse in the kitchen.

If you find one in good condition, it could be worth more than you expect. They’re not just nostalgic; they’re also built to last.

Mid-Century Bakelite Measuring Cups

I’ve always been drawn to mid-century kitchen tools, and Bakelite measuring cups are a favorite. These cups were made from an early plastic known for being heat resistant and durable.

Because Bakelite is no longer produced, authentic measuring cups from this era are becoming harder to find. I’ve noticed collectors pay good money for cups with bright colors or unique shapes.

If you stumble upon a set, check for condition carefully. Chips or cracks can lower the value, but a complete, vibrant set usually catches attention.

Rare Anchor Hocking Fire-King Glassware

I’ve always been fascinated by Anchor Hocking’s Fire-King glassware. These pieces were made starting in the 1940s and were designed for everyday use, but some patterns and colors have become quite collectible over time.

One example is their Jadeite line, the mint-green glass that many mid-century kitchens featured. It’s especially popular now because of its unique color and sturdy design. I’ve noticed that bolder colors and rarer prints tend to attract the most attention from collectors.

Finding a piece with its original graphics or in excellent condition makes it even more valuable. I always keep an eye out for Fire-King when I’m thrifting because you never know what vintage treasure you might find.