Thrifting turns ordinary afternoons into small treasure hunts, and vintage cookie jars are the kind of find that can brighten a shelf and your wallet. You’ll follow shapes, makers, and little design clues as you scan aisles, learning to spot pieces that carry collector interest.
You’ll walk away knowing which seven jars deserve your attention and why they matter to collectors and kitchen lovers alike. The rest of the article dives into recognizable makers, iconic figural styles, and practical ID tips so you can spot the worthwhile jars when they show up on the thrift shelf.
McCoy Pottery Cookie Jars
You’ll spot McCoy cookie jars by their playful shapes and thick, glossy glazes that feel vintage in your hand.
Condition and markings matter — intact glaze and a clear McCoy stamp usually raise interest.
Some patterns like animals and roosters appear often, but rarer motifs fetch higher prices.
Check bases and lids carefully; chips and repainting drop value quickly.
Learn common marks and compare similar listings before you buy.
This helps you decide if a find is a deal or just decorative.
Inarco Figural Cookie Jars
You’ll spot Inarco pieces by their glossy glaze and playful figural shapes.
Look for mid-century themes—fruit, animals, and whimsical characters—often marked Japan or Inarco on the base.
These jars can show crazing or minor chips; that won’t ruin their display value.
Check listings and photos carefully if buying online, and compare to known examples like a 1960 Inarco Mood Indigo jar to verify styling.
Chase Cookie Jars
You’ll spot Chase cookie jars by their cartoonish police or dog designs that feel playful and nostalgic.
They often date from mid‑20th century to the 1970s and can show bright glazes with minor crazing.
Check maker marks under the base and look for intact lids and paint—condition drives value more than age.
If you find one at a thrift store, compare it to online listings for similar motifs before you buy.
Hull Pottery Cookie Jars
You’ll spot Hull Pottery jars by their earthy glazes and solid, vintage feel.
Look for iconic pieces like Little Red Riding Hood; these show up at thrift stores and resale sites.
Condition matters: chips, crazing, or missing lids cut value, so inspect pieces closely.
Check current listings on marketplaces like eBay to compare prices and confirm marks before you buy.
Goebel Hummel Cookie Jars
You’ll recognize Hummel cookie jars by their hand-painted, childlike figurines and the Goebel mark on the base.
These pieces were made in West Germany and, when in good condition with clear markings, they attract collectors.
Handle them gently and check for chips, hairline cracks, and any restored paint.
If you find one at a thrift store, compare markings and photos online to confirm authenticity before deciding.
See listings and examples on eBay for comparison.
Shawnee Corn King Cookie Jar
You’ll spot the Shawnee Corn King by its bright yellow ears and green husks — a classic mid‑century look collectors love.
Produced by Shawnee Pottery from the 1940s–1950s, it often measures about 10 inches tall and can show age wear like small chips.
If you find one at a thrift shop, check the lid fit and any hairline cracks before buying.
Values vary by condition, but a clean Corn King can be a fun, affordable vintage display piece.
Roseville Pottery Cookie Jars
You’ll spot Roseville pieces by their smooth glazes and subtle floral or geometric motifs.
They were made in Ohio from the early 1900s through mid-century and often show maker marks on the base.
A well-preserved Roseville jar can attract collectors, so check for chips, hairlines, and intact glazing.
Browse listings to compare patterns and prices, for example on the Roseville cookie jar collection at eBay.
More from Decluttering Mom: