Ah, the 90s! A time when our biggest worries were whether our Tamagotchi was fed or if we could snag the latest Pokémon cards. If you grew up in that glorious decade, you probably have a few toys tucked away in the attic, buried in the depths of nostalgia. But guess what? Those childhood treasures might just be worth a small fortune today. That’s right! Your old toys could fund a spontaneous trip to Cancun or at least a nice dinner out. Let’s take a stroll down memory lane and see which 90s toys are now hot commodities!
Beanie Babies: The Holy Grail of Collectibles
First up on our nostalgia tour are Beanie Babies. These cute little plush critters took the world by storm, and let’s be honest, we all thought we’d become millionaires by hoarding them. Some of the rarest ones, especially the “Princess Diana” bear, can fetch thousands at auction. It’s wild to think that a little stuffed animal could be worth more than your first car! If you’ve got a stash at home, it might be time to dust them off and see if you’ve got a collector’s gem.
Pokémon Cards: Gotta Catch ‘Em All (Again)

Who didn’t spend countless hours trading Pokémon cards during recess? Fast forward to today, and those cards are more than just nostalgic memorabilia; they’re serious investments. A first edition Charizard card can sell for upwards of $200,000! Yes, you read that right. If you’ve got a collection lingering in a shoebox somewhere, it may be worth sorting through. Just be careful—if you find a Charizard, handle it like the treasure it is!
Furby: The Cuddly Robot That Could
Remember Furby? That little creature that spoke a mix of English and “Furbish”? They were everywhere in the late 90s, and while they may have terrified some with their unpredictable antics, collectors can’t get enough of them today. Certain models, especially the original ones in their pristine packaging, can fetch up to $500. Just think, that little furry friend from your childhood could help pay for your next big purchase. Who knew robots could be so valuable?
Tamagotchi: The Original Digital Pet
The Tamagotchi was the ultimate responsibility test for kids in the 90s. Can you keep a virtual pet alive? The answer was often a resounding “no,” but some of those little egg-shaped gadgets have turned into collectible gold. Original versions, particularly the rare colors and designs, can sell for over $1,000! So, if you’ve still got your old Tamagotchi, it might be time to see if it still works—just watch out for that death screen!
Barbie: A Timeless Classic
Barbies have always been iconic, but some of the vintage dolls from the 90s are now worth more than a few bucks. Limited edition dolls, like the 1992 “Happy Holidays Barbie,” can be valued at around $1,000 or more if they’re in good condition. If you’ve been holding onto your childhood Barbie collection, it’s worth checking out what you’ve got. Who knows, you might just be sitting on a gold mine of fashionable plastic!
Nerf Guns: The Ultimate Battle Gear
Ah, Nerf guns—the perfect excuse for a friendly battle in the backyard. Some of the original models, especially the rare ones, can be worth quite a bit today. Vintage Nerf guns can go for $100 or more, especially if you’ve kept them in good shape. So if you’re still packing heat with your old arsenal, take a moment to appreciate what those foam darts could be worth!
Action Figures: More Than Just Toys
Let’s not forget the action figures that ruled our childhoods. Whether you were into G.I. Joe or the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, some of those figures are now collectibles that can command impressive prices. A mint-condition original G.I. Joe from the 90s? That could run you over $1,000! If your basement’s hiding some plastic heroes, it might be time to take a trip down memory lane—or a trip to the auction house!
More from Decluttering Mom:













