Detectives in Pennsylvania say they walked into what looked like a set from a low-budget slasher, only it was real life. Inside a modest home in Ephrata, investigators say they uncovered more than 100 skulls, mummified limbs and the remains of infants and children, all allegedly pulled from historic graves and mausoleums. The man at the center of the case, 34-year-old Jonathan Christ Gerlach, is now accused of turning human bodies into inventory.
What started as a quiet investigation into cemetery burglaries has spiraled into a sprawling case that touches grieving families, a crumbling burial ground and an underground market for bones. The details are graphic, but they also raise a blunt question: how did a “house of horrors” like this sit in the middle of a neighborhood without anyone realizing what was stacked in the basement?
The “house of horrors” and the man accused of filling it
Investigators say the trail to Ephrata began with a string of break-ins at Mount Moriah Cemetery in Delaware County, a sprawling burial ground that advocates with Friends of Mount describe as the country’s largest abandoned gravesite. Police say mausoleums were forced open and coffins disturbed, with thieves targeting skulls and other easily carried bones. As detectives dug into the burglaries, they checked a vehicle plate tied to the scene and, according to one account, that search led them to a home in Ephrata and to a man they identified as Gerlach, whose name later surfaced in court records.
Inside, Detectives say they found shelves lined with skulls, loose bones in containers and what one prosecutor described as “a horror movie come to life.” Authorities estimate there were Over 100 skulls in the house and in a storage unit, along with full skeletons and preserved tissue. In one traffic stop, They say they pulled a burlap bag from his vehicle that held the mummified remains of two small children, three skulls and other bones, details later laid out in a charging document. A separate search of his basement turned up 100 skulls and mummified body parts, a haul that investigators linked back to the same historic cemetery through evidence from the.
From graveyard burglaries to an alleged bone market
Police say the man at the center of this is not some shadowy figure out of folklore but Jonathan Christ Gerlach, a 34-year-old Pennsylvania resident whose name and age, 34-year-old, appear in multiple social posts. One clip shared on Jan shows a caption noting that Police say 34-year-old Gerlach is facing a long list of charges, a detail echoed in a reel that picked up 85 likes and framed the case as something viewers had never seen the LIKE THIS BEFORE in the COLD early days of the year. Another post spells out that a 34-year-old Pennsylvania man, identified as Jonathan Gerlach of Ephrata, is accused of breaking into mausoleums and hauling away remains, a description that matches what investigators later laid out in charging paperwork.
According to a detailed warrant, detectives say Gerlach admitted he was not just collecting but also selling some of the bones, allegedly moving skulls and other pieces to buyers he met online. A narrative filed by Grace Miller describes how, by the time officers searched his home and a house next door, they had already tied him to sales of human remains and were tracking down who might have purchased them, a process laid out in warrant records. Another account notes that Police say Jonathan Christ Gerlach, 34, is facing more than 100 criminal counts tied to grave robbery and abuse of a corpse, a tally that surfaced in a post with 2,021 likes that bluntly reminded followers that he is still presumed innocent until proven guilty and referenced 100 separate remains.
Victims, neighbors and a system that missed the warning signs
For families with loved ones buried at Mount Moriah, the allegations land like a second funeral. One detailed account of the case notes that Over 100 pieces of human remains were taken from the Pennsylvania cemetery, including skulls, vertebrae and long bones that may have belonged to people buried hundreds of years ago. Authorities say some of the bodies were so old that records are spotty, which complicates efforts to match bones to names and notify descendants, a frustration echoed in another report that stressed how the investigation remains ongoing and that officials are still working to identify additional remains and secure a $1,000,000 bail for him in court records.
Back in Ephrata, neighbors are still processing how a man accused of turning his basement into a bone warehouse lived among them without raising alarms. A video labeled as the Jonathan Gerlach case shows Neighbors reacting to police finding skeletons in the basement, with some saying they had no idea what was happening next door until cruisers and crime scene tape flooded the block, a reaction captured in a YouTube clip. Another report describes how Detectives, speaking from WASHINGTON, said they “walked into a horror movie come to life in that home” and warned that the case is still widening as they trace remains from the house, the storage locker and the historic cemetery, a stark summary embedded in a broadcast report. As the case moves toward a preliminary hearing set for Jan. 20, outlined in documents that also detail how, On Wednesday, Gerlach’s fiancé pointed detectives to a storage locker and a $1,000,000 bail request, the community is left to wonder how many more graves were disturbed before anyone noticed, a question that hangs over the latest filings.
The fallout has rippled beyond one neighborhood. Transit riders in the region were told that SEPTA Regional Rail express trains would return to regular service on Monday even as the investigation into the cemetery thefts continued, a reminder in local updates that life goes on around the crime scene. Police say Jonathan Christ Gerlach, identified in one brief as a 34-year-old Pennsylvania man from Ephrata, is being held on a long list of felony counts tied to grave robbery and abuse of a corpse, charges that sit alongside a separate note that Police had been looking into the string of burglaries when they ran his plates and found his name was listed in court records. For now, the case is a grim collision of decaying infrastructure, online bone trading and a justice system scrambling to catch up, with Pennsylvania authorities still counting remains and families waiting to hear whether the bones in that basement once belonged to someone they loved.
More from Decluttering Mom:
