When You Catch a Coworker Red-Handed

Picture this: you’re at work, sipping on your third cup of coffee, trying to catch up on emails when you notice something a little…off. Your coworker, let’s call her Sarah, seems to be acting strangely. You’ve seen her sneaking around the supply closet a bit too often, and today, she’s got a stash of office supplies that would make a small store jealous. You think, “No way, not Sarah!” But deep down, you know you’ve got a dilemma on your hands: do you report her or look the other way?
What Happens When You See Something?
First off, it’s important to understand that witnessing a coworker stealing can put you in a tough position. On one hand, there’s your moral compass pointing you toward honesty and integrity, and on the other, there’s the awkward reality of potentially ruining someone’s career. It’s like being stuck between a rock and a hard place, right?
In the workplace, trust is everything. You want to feel safe knowing that you’re all in this together, and that everyone’s playing by the same rules. When someone breaks that trust, it’s not just about the supplies they’re pocketing; it’s about the culture of the whole team. And let’s be honest, nobody wants to work in an environment where you have to keep an eye on your stapler.
The Dilemma: To Report or Not to Report?
So you’re sitting there, contemplating your next move. You could report Sarah to your manager, but that would mean her job is on the line. And let’s face it, no one wants to feel like the office snitch. But if you don’t say anything, are you complicit in her actions? It’s a real head-scratcher.
Before you make any hasty decisions, consider the consequences. If Sarah’s stealing from the office, she might be doing it from her own desperation. Maybe she’s struggling financially and convinced herself that “borrowing” a few pens won’t hurt anyone. Or perhaps it’s a case of entitlement—like she thinks the company owes her something. Either way, it’s worth taking a moment to think about her side of the story.
Gather Your Evidence
If you do decide that reporting is the right course of action, make sure you’ve got your facts straight. You don’t want to be that person who makes accusations without any solid proof. Keep track of what you’ve seen. Maybe you noticed Sarah carrying out boxes of supplies or overheard her bragging about her “great finds” during lunch. Documenting your observations might seem like a bit much, but it could save you from a lot of headaches down the road.
Also, consider whether others have noticed her behavior. Sometimes, it helps to have a buddy in these situations. Just make sure it’s someone you trust and not another potential gossip. You don’t want your coworker to get wind of your plans before you’re ready to take action!
Approaching the Situation
If you’re feeling brave enough to report her, how you approach this can make a world of difference. Consider talking to your manager privately and framing it as a concern for the workplace environment, rather than a personal attack on Sarah. Use phrases like, “I’ve noticed some unusual behavior,” rather than “I caught her stealing.” This can help soften the blow and make it clear you’re not out to get her.
At the same time, be prepared for the possibility that your manager may not take action. Sometimes, companies have their own ways of handling these situations, and they may decide to give Sarah a warning instead of jumping straight to firing her. It can be frustrating, but remember: you did your part by bringing it to light.
Maybe There’s a Middle Ground?
Now, if you’re really torn and don’t want to go straight to management, you might consider having a heart-to-heart with Sarah first. Approach her casually, maybe over lunch or coffee, and ask if everything’s okay. You could say something like, “Hey, I’ve noticed you’ve been really busy with supplies lately. Is there something going on?” This could lead to an honest conversation, and who knows? Maybe she’ll admit that she’s been struggling and just needs someone to talk to.
Of course, there’s a risk that she’ll get defensive or deny everything. If that happens, you’ll have to decide if you want to escalate the situation or let it go.
More from Decluttering Mom:













