Have you ever stumbled upon an old, interesting cookie jar at a garage sale, or maybe tucked away in your grandmother’s kitchen and wondered if it might be worth anything? If it is a McCoy cookie jar, you could be holding onto a small fortune. McCoy pottery has been a staple of American ceramics for over a century, and their cookie jars are among the most sought after by collectors. This isn’t just about antiquated kitchenware; it’s about preserving and appreciating a slice of Americana. In this article, we’ll provide a guide for identifying McCoy cookie jars and their current market prices, derived from real-world trends and expert insights.
McCoy Wishing Well Cookie Jar
The McCoy Wishing Well cookie jar is a classic designed in the 1950s. The jar is shaped like a rustic stone well with a wooden roof and bucket. The words “Oh Wishing Well, Grant A Wish To Me” are inscribed on the side. If you come across one in good condition, it can fetch up to $100.
McCoy Clown Cookie Jar
Made in the early 1940s, the McCoy Clown cookie jar is a rare find. It features a cheerful clown holding a large cookie. The vivid colors and unique design make this a favorite among collectors. A well-preserved McCoy Clown cookie jar may cost you anywhere between $200 and $300.
McCoy Apple Cookie Jar
The McCoy Apple cookie jar, modeled after a ripe red apple with a leafy green stem, is a staple among McCoy pottery. Produced in the 1950s, it’s a charming piece that can bring up to $75 in good condition.
McCoy Bear Cookie Jar
The McCoy Bear cookie jar is a delightful piece from the 1940s. It features a smiling bear holding a “Honey” pot. This adorable jar is a sought-after collectible and can command prices of $150 – $200.
McCoy cookie jars are more than just nostalgic kitchenware; they’re collectible pieces of American history. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just starting, identifying and pricing these jars can be an exciting journey into the past. Remember, the value lies not just in the monetary worth but also in the joy of discovery and the appreciation of artistry and history.
