Nineteen-year-old Nicole Bennett set out alone to hike near southern Utah’s Red Cliffs Recreation Area and never came home. After an overnight search, a relative who joined the effort spotted her along a rugged trail, where authorities say she had fallen and died in a treacherous section of desert terrain. Her death has shaken a tight-knit community and renewed scrutiny of how quickly a routine outing can turn deadly in the canyons outside St. George.
Investigators now describe the case as a tragic accident, but the details of Nicole’s final hours, the search that followed, and the family’s role in finding her have raised hard questions about solo hiking, backcountry preparedness, and the limits of rescue operations in steep red rock country. Friends and relatives are also working to honor a young woman they say was deeply committed to her faith and preparing to serve a mission for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
The hike that became a missing-person case
Nicole Bennett left for what was expected to be a short solo hike near the Red Cliffs Recreation Area in Washington County, Utah, a landscape of slot canyons and sandstone ridges that draws visitors from across the region. Family members reported her missing late on a Monday night after she did not return, and deputies soon learned that her vehicle was parked at the popular trailhead near the boundary of the Red Cliffs National Conservation Area, not far from the historic ruins at Harrisburg. The location placed her somewhere in a maze of trails and washes that can be confusing even for locals who know the Red Cliffs area well.
Authorities treated the report as an urgent missing-person case because Nicole was only 19 and believed to be hiking alone in winter conditions that can turn cold and windy after dark. Washington County search and rescue teams mobilized overnight, focusing on routes that connect the Red Cliffs Recreation Area to the Red Reef Trail and nearby canyons. The sheriff’s office later confirmed that her vehicle had been found at the same trailhead where many visitors begin day hikes, underscoring how quickly a familiar starting point can lead to danger once someone leaves the parking lot alone.
Search efforts in Washington County’s red rock country
Once Nicole was reported missing, Washington County Sheriff’s Office coordinated a multi-pronged search that stretched through the night and into the next morning. Teams on foot and in vehicles fanned out from the Red Cliffs Recreation Area, while others moved toward the Red Reef Trail, a route that winds through narrow canyons and steep slickrock. The sheriff’s office later acknowledged in a formal FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE that they were “saddened” by the outcome, describing how crews had worked through difficult terrain to try to locate the teenager.
Local reports from St. George detailed how searchers concentrated near a Washington County campground and along the Red Reef Trail, where the landscape includes exposed ledges and drop-offs that can be hazardous, particularly in low light. One account from St. GEORGE, Utah, noted that the body of a 19-year-old girl who had been reported missing was ultimately found early on a Wednesday morning in the Red Cli area, after teams had already covered large portions of the canyon system in the dark. The scale of the operation, described in coverage of the investigation, underscored how challenging it can be to find a single hiker in a vast and rugged conservation area.
A family member’s heartbreaking discovery on the trail
Despite the professional search effort, it was a relative who ultimately found Nicole. After learning that her vehicle was still parked at the Red Cliffs Recreation Area, family members joined the search and began hiking the same routes she was believed to have taken. According to a detailed account that summarized key facts under the heading NEED TO KNOW, Nicole Bennett, 19, had been reported missing on Jan. 13 and her vehicle was located at the Red Cliffs Recreation Area before a family member spotted her body in what authorities later described as a treacherous hiking area. That account, which emphasized that a family member was the one to discover her, has become central to public understanding of how the search ended.
Another report described how a 19-year-old woman who had been reported missing late Monday night was later found deceased, with Washington County Sheriff’s Office Sgt. Lucas Alfred Paul explaining that preliminary findings indicated her death was accidental and that she likely fell. That same account noted that Nicole left to go hiking and never returned, and that it was a relative who discovered Nicole’s body before authorities could reach the spot. The description of Paul’s comments, preserved in a post that shared condolences and prayers for Nicole’s family, highlighted how quickly the search shifted from a rescue to a recovery once Paul briefed the public.
What investigators say about how Nicole died
From the outset, Washington County authorities signaled that they did not suspect foul play in Nicole’s death. Sgt. Lucas Alfred Paul said that preliminary findings indicated her death was accidental and that she likely fell in a steep section of the trail, a conclusion that aligned with the description of the area as “treacherous” in several accounts. The sheriff’s office reiterated in its formal RELEASE that the 19 YEAR OLD female had been located deceased in Washington County and asked the public to respect the family’s privacy while the investigation continued.
Local television coverage from ST. GEORGE, Utah, reported that the body of a 19-year-old girl who had been reported missing was found near a Washington County campground on the Red Reef Trail, and that investigators believed she had fallen in a hazardous section of the route. A separate report framed the case under the stark headline that a Missing 19-year-old had been found dead near Red Cliffs Recreation Area in Washington County, noting that search teams had to navigate a wide area to reach the spot where she was located. That coverage, which described the extent of the search area and the proximity to Red Cliffs Recreation Area in Washington County, reinforced the sheriff’s assessment that Nicole’s death was the result of a fall rather than any criminal act.
Red Cliffs Recreation Area’s beauty and hidden risks
The Red Cliffs Recreation Area sits within the larger Red Cliffs National Conservation Area, a protected landscape of red sandstone, desert vegetation, and archaeological sites that has become a magnet for hikers and photographers. Trails like Red Reef and the routes near the ruins of Harrisburg offer sweeping views and narrow canyons, but they also include exposed slickrock, seasonal pools, and drop-offs that can be difficult to navigate without experience. A local report on another fatal incident in the area described how the ruins of a Harrisburg home sit next to the National Conservation Area boundary line at Red Cliffs Recrea, underscoring how close historic sites and high-risk terrain sit to one another in this National Conservation Area.
Officials and local rescuers have long warned that the same features that make the region picturesque can also make it perilous, particularly for solo hikers or visitors who underestimate the difficulty of the trails. Reports on Nicole’s case repeatedly referred to the section where she was found as a “treacherous” hiking area, language that mirrors earlier coverage of other falls near Red Cliffs Recrea and the surrounding canyons. The combination of steep rock, sudden changes in elevation, and limited cell service means that a single misstep can leave a hiker stranded or worse, even within sight of a popular campground or the main Red Reef Trail.
Community grief for a young woman preparing for a mission
As news of Nicole’s death spread, friends and family described a young woman whose life was rooted in faith and service. One detailed account explained that Nicole was preparing to serve a mission for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and had been called to serve in Italy, a milestone that underscored how abruptly her plans were cut short. The same report, written by Ava Hart and Abigail Jones, noted that it had been reported to the sheriff’s office that her vehicle was located at the Red Cliffs Recre trailhead before she was found, and that her community in Idaho and Utah was now mourning a woman who had been looking ahead to her time as a missionary in Italy.
Social media posts shared by relatives and acquaintances echoed that portrait, with commenters expressing heartbreak and offering prayers for Nicole’s parents and siblings. One widely shared message described how Nicole left to go hiking and never returned, and how her family was now planning her funeral instead of celebrating her mission call. The tone of those tributes, many of which referenced her membership in The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and her desire to serve, highlighted the depth of the loss felt by those who knew Nicole personally.
Warnings about solo hiking and “treacherous” routes
Nicole’s death has intensified long-standing warnings about hiking alone in rugged parts of Utah. In one summary of the case, the NEED TO KNOW section emphasized that Nicole Bennett, 19, had been reported missing after heading out by herself and that her vehicle was later found at the Red Cliffs Recreation Area before she was discovered in a treacherous hiking area. Another account from Utah framed the tragedy as a cautionary tale, noting that a family in Utah is in mourning after a missing young woman was found dead and that Nicole Bennett had gone hiking, allegedly on a trail she had researched on Google Maps, before suffering a fatal fall in a dangerous section of the trail.
Local coverage of another fatal fall near Red Cliffs Recrea, involving an 18-year-old woman who died while hiking alone, has been cited alongside Nicole’s case as evidence that even experienced hikers can underestimate the risks. That earlier report described how family and friends said the woman died while hiking alone near the Red Cliffs Recreation area, and it included comments from a Sgt. who underscored the dangers of venturing into the National Conservation Area without a partner. Together, these incidents have prompted renewed calls from rescuers and community members for hikers to avoid going out alone, to carry reliable navigation tools instead of relying solely on apps, and to recognize that even well-known routes in Utah can turn deadly when conditions or judgment slip.
How officials and rescuers are responding
In the days after Nicole’s body was found, Washington County Sheriff’s Office used its public platforms to both share condolences and reinforce safety messages. The office’s FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE about the MISSING 19 YEAR OLD FEMALE LOCATED DECEASED WASHINGTON COUNTY expressed sorrow and asked for privacy, but it also implicitly highlighted the scale of the search and the difficulty of the terrain where she was found. That statement, shared widely on social media, became a focal point for community discussion about how search and rescue teams operate in the Red Cliffs area and what more can be done to prevent similar tragedies, including clearer signage and more detailed warnings at the trailhead.
Rescuers and local law enforcement have also pointed to the limits of their capabilities when hikers go missing in steep, remote sections of the National Conservation Area. Coverage of the Missing 19-year-old found dead near Red Cliffs Recreation Area in Washington County noted that teams had to expand the extent of the search area significantly once it became clear that Nicole might have left the main trail, a reminder that even a large, well-coordinated response can take hours to reach someone in distress. Another report from ST. GEORGE, Utah, which detailed how the body of a 19-year-old girl was found near a Washington County campground, underscored that the Red Cliffs Recreation Area and surrounding canyons will likely remain popular despite the risks, leaving officials to balance access with ongoing efforts to educate visitors about the hazards of the Red Cliffs Recreation.
More from Decluttering Mom:
