A mother who discovers that her former partner has claimed their children on a tax return despite paying no support is not just facing an emotional betrayal, but a concrete financial hit. The stakes include lost refunds, delayed filings and, in some cases, an IRS audit that can drag on for months. Yet the tax code gives custodial parents clear leverage if they understand how dependency rules work and how to push back when an ex crosses the line.
At the center of these disputes is a basic question: who is legally allowed to claim a child, and under what conditions can that right be shared or transferred after a breakup. The answer turns on custody, specific IRS forms and a paper trail that can matter more than whatever a family court judge said about support.
Who really gets to claim the kids?
Under federal rules, the starting point is simple: the custodial parent, the one the child lives with for more nights during the year, is generally the only person who can claim that child as a dependent. IRS guidance explains that to claim someone as a dependent, a taxpayer must meet tests tied to relationship, residency and support, and it is explicit that Answer, You must show the child lived with you long enough and did not provide more than half of their own support. That framework means an ex who rarely sees the children and pays no support has no automatic right to the tax benefits that come with listing them on a return.
There is, however, a narrow path for a noncustodial parent to claim certain benefits if the custodial parent agrees in writing. The IRS created Form 8332 so a custodial parent can sign a formal release of the dependency claim for a given year or years. Tax professionals stress that this release is voluntary and can be revoked, and that without it, the noncustodial parent cannot lawfully take the child tax credit or similar breaks. When a mother discovers her ex has claimed the kids without such a release, she is usually on firm ground to challenge the filing.
Why child support and tax rights do not automatically match
Many parents assume that whoever pays child support gets to claim the children, but the tax code does not work that way. A detailed breakdown of support and dependency rules notes that child support itself is not deductible and does not, by itself, create a right to claim a dependent, even when the payer believes they are covering most expenses. One guide framed the issue under the heading Can a noncustodial parent claim a child, and answered that the noncustodial parent must attach a signed release from the custodial parent, not just proof of payments.
That distinction becomes critical when an ex is behind on support or has never paid at all. Family law practitioners emphasize that even a court order about who may claim a child does not override IRS rules if the paperwork the agency requires is missing. One legal analysis, under a section labeled Bottom Line, explains that if a former partner wrongfully claims the children, the custodial parent can still file correctly and pursue the dependent credits they are owed, regardless of what the ex has done. In other words, a mother whose ex pays nothing is not required to surrender tax benefits just because a support order exists on paper.
When an ex files first and the IRS rejects the return
For many parents, the first sign of trouble is a rejected e-filed return. Tax software and IRS systems will not accept two returns with the same child’s Social Security number, and guidance on duplicate claims stresses that The SSN must match IRS records and can only be used once per year. When an ex has already filed, the custodial parent’s electronic return will bounce back with an error, even if she is the only one legally entitled to claim the child.
At that point, experts advise shifting from e-filing to paper. One step-by-step guide explains that a parent in this situation should print and mail a return that still claims the child, then wait for the IRS to sort out who is entitled to the dependency. The same resource notes that at any time, a taxpayer can contact the IRS to alert them to the matter, which can trigger a review and, if needed, an examination of both parents’ filings.
How the IRS breaks the tie and what letters to expect
Once two parents claim the same child, the IRS does not simply side with whoever filed first. Instead, the agency applies a set of “tie breaker” rules that favor the custodial parent and, if necessary, the parent with the higher adjusted gross income. A detailed FAQ on the child tax credit explains that in general, Question may a noncustodial parent claim the child tax credit is answered with a clear Answer, Yes only if the custodial parent has released the claim. Without that release, the noncustodial parent’s return is vulnerable.
Parents caught in this situation should also watch their mail. IRS identity theft guidance notes that You may receive a letter, known as CP87A, stating that a child was claimed on another return and explaining what to do next. A separate overview of duplicate dependent claims explains that Jan you will get a letter if someone else has claimed your dependent, and that both taxpayers may be asked to provide proof such as school records, medical bills or custody agreements.
The crucial role of Form 8332 and written releases
In disputes where an ex insists they had permission to claim a child, the IRS looks for one document above all others. The agency’s own instructions explain that a noncustodial parent must attach Form titled Release and Revocation of Release of Claim to Exemptio to claim the child as a dependent. Without that signed release, the IRS will generally side with the custodial parent, even if a divorce decree says something different.
Tax practitioners underscore that timing matters too. One explanation of what is IRS Form 8332 notes that the custodial parent should file their return as early as possible so the other parent cannot slip in a competing claim. If the noncustodial parent files first, the IRS may still disallow their claim once it sees that no valid release exists, but the process can take months and delay refunds for both sides.
Legal and practical steps when an ex will not play fair
For a mother whose ex has claimed the children without paying support, the tax fight is often only half the story. Family law attorneys point out that wrongful tax claims can also violate custody or support orders, opening the door to sanctions in state court. In one video aimed at separated parents, attorney Bobby Buchanan in Illinois explains from Chicago that parents should distinguish between what a judge ordered and what the IRS will actually honor, and that they may need to pursue both tax remedies and contempt motions when an ex ignores the rules.
Online forums show how messy these cases can become in real life. In one discussion, a taxpayer posting under the heading Jan was told there is no way to expedite an IRS decision if both parents claim the same child, but that they can still file on paper and let the agency resolve the false claim. Another thread, labeled Jun, explains that if someone else claimed your child inappropriately and filed first, your e-file will be rejected and you will receive the same letter your ex does, forcing both of you to prove your case.
Why documentation and persistence usually win
Ultimately, the parent who can show where the child actually lives and who provides day-to-day care is in the strongest position. Custody-focused guidance notes that If the noncustodial parent claims a child without permission, the IRS may enforce its rules and disallow the claim once it reviews the facts. The same resource explains that When the IRS steps in, it can adjust refunds, assess penalties and, in some cases, bar a parent from claiming certain credits in future years.
Parents navigating this maze often turn to peer advice as well as professionals. One widely shared comment on a legal forum begins with Someone pointing out that the IRS issue is separate from family court, and urging the custodial parent to Look for a signed Form 8332 before assuming the ex had any right to claim the child. For the mother who discovers her ex has taken the kids on his taxes without paying a dime of support, the message is consistent: document custody, file correctly, respond to IRS letters and let the paper trail, not the ex’s story, decide who gets the refund.
More from Decluttering Mom:
