One young woman left her psychiatrist’s office caught off guard by a mix of compliments and unexpected suggestions. At just 20 years old, she had begun seeing the psychiatrist for help with suspected ADHD, but her appointments had shifted focus toward her struggles with depression. After her latest session, she couldn’t shake off the uneasy feeling that something had gone awry.
During the last appointment, she found it hard to explain her feelings. Whenever she started to share, the psychiatrist interrupted her. At one point, he bluntly told her to “stop.” This disregard made her feel as though her thoughts didn’t matter. To make things worse, he insisted that she bring her parents to the next appointment or, even more oddly, call her mom while she was there. While some might interpret this suggestion as a genuine concern for her well-being, she felt pressured rather than supported. As the session drew to a close, she left feeling close to tears.
Reflecting on the appointment, she recalled prior incidents that had left her feeling uncomfortable. The psychiatrist often complimented her appearance, calling her “beautiful” and suggesting that her slender figure resembled that of a model. He had even inquired if she danced, which felt a bit out of place in a professional setting. More troubling were his repeated questions about what she discussed with her therapist, including whether their talks involved her romantic life. After consistently emphasizing that her struggles with depression weren’t due to relationship issues, she felt frustrated that he continued to reduce her experiences to a mere boy problem.
In one peculiar moment, she mentioned the vivid dreams brought on by her medication, to which he promptly asked if they were erotic. This line of questioning felt invasive and unprofessional. His habit of initiating high-fives or handshakes unexpectedly added to her discomfort, making her wonder whether these behaviors were typical in clinical settings.
To top it all off, as she was leaving, he surprised her with two concert tickets, instructing her not to tell anyone about them. Caught off guard, she accepted them, but guilt followed her as soon as she left his office. Realizing that the situation felt wrong, she called back to decline the tickets. Her psychiatrist responded with multiple calls, expressing concern about her discomfort and explaining that the tickets were actually for his son, who couldn’t attend.
Now, she grappled with conflicting feelings. Part of her worried she was overreacting, and she felt guilty about questioning a professional. She didn’t want to unfairly accuse someone who might be trying to help. Still, the cumulative effect of her experiences led her to wonder if something was indeed off. Should she discuss these concerns with her therapist, or was she making too much of it? As a first-time patient with a psychiatrist, she felt unsure of how to navigate these feelings.
People had very different reactions to her story. Some thought she had every right to feel uncomfortable, pointing out that a psychiatrist’s primary role should be to create a safe environment for discussion. Others suggested she might be misinterpreting his intentions, arguing that compliments and personal questions could stem from a well-meaning but unprofessional approach. A few advised her to trust her instincts, emphasizing the importance of a supportive therapeutic relationship.
As the young woman weighs her next steps, she’s left with a lingering question: how does one define the boundaries of professionalism in therapy, especially when personal feelings and behaviors come into play?
More from Decluttering Mom:
