A mother who once leaned hard on old-school discipline is now looking at her family and wishing she had tried something softer with her first two kids. Instead of staying stuck in that regret, she is shifting how she parents her younger children, trying to repair trust and rewrite patterns in real time. Her story lands right in the middle of a wider cultural argument over what “gentle parenting” actually is and whether it helps kids thrive or leaves them floundering.
Her pivot is not about chasing a trend. It is about recognizing that the way adults were raised often shows up in how they talk to their own kids, then deciding that cycle can stop with them. That mix of remorse, reflection, and course correction is what makes her experience feel so familiar to parents who are quietly wondering if it is too late to do things differently.
From old-school rules to a late-in-life reset
When her oldest children were small, she followed the script she knew best: firm rules, quick consequences, and a belief that respect flowed from control. She has described relying on what she calls old-school parenting, the kind that prizes obedience and fast compliance over long conversations. Back then, “gentle parenting” sounded to her like a soft option, something that would spoil kids or leave them running the house. She had absorbed the common misconception that being calm and collaborative meant never saying no, so she doubled down on what felt familiar instead.
Over time, though, the cracks in that approach started to show. Her older kids listened, but they did not always open up. They followed directions, yet she sensed a distance that discipline alone could not bridge. That discomfort pushed her to look more closely at what gentle parenting actually involves as a technique, rather than the caricature she had dismissed. She began to see that the method is less about permissiveness and more about teaching consequences through connection and trust, a shift that made her wonder what might have been different if she had understood that sooner.
Making it right with the younger kids
By the time her younger children arrived, she was ready to try again with a different playbook. Writer Rachel Garlinghouse has described a similar shift, explaining how she is “making up for lost time” by leaning into calmer conversations, clear boundaries, and predictable follow-through. Instead of defaulting to raised voices, she walks younger kids through what went wrong, what needs to change, and how they can repair the situation. The goal is not to erase consequences but to make sure those consequences feel fair and connected to the behavior, not to her mood.
That reset also means owning the past out loud. She has told her older children that she wishes she had known more about gentle parenting when they were small, a move that mirrors how other parents are starting to talk openly about regret. For her younger kids, the difference shows up in daily routines: more chances to explain their feelings, more collaborative problem solving, and a lot more time spent practicing skills like saving allowance or managing screen time instead of waiting until it is allowance time again and everyone is upset. The shift is slow and imperfect, but it is deliberate.
Gentle parenting, regret, and the backlash cycle
Her story is unfolding alongside a louder backlash, where some parents now say gentle parenting itself was the mistake. One regretful mom has argued that a decade of trying to stay endlessly calm and conscious left her kids anxious and entitled, not grounded. In another viral account, a mother said she thought she was doing everything right with a gentle approach, then watched as one child grew more withdrawn and another more defiant. A separate account from a mother who spent ten years in that style described kids who were anxious, entitled, and emotionally dysregulated, a pattern she shared in a viral reflection that resonated with parents who felt they had gone too far in the other direction.
Those stories sit in tension with parents like Rachel Garlinghouse, who argue that there are a lot of misconceptions about what gentle parenting is supposed to look like in practice. She and others stress that it does not mean kids are spoiled or free from limits, a point echoed in reporting that notes, “There are a lot of misconceptions about gentle parenting. Let me be clear, gentle parenting does not mean that kids are spoiled,” a line that appears in a widely shared essay. For the mom trying to repair things with her younger children, that nuance matters. She is not chasing a label. She is Reflecting on how she was raised, how she raised her oldest kids, and what kind of relationship she wants with all of them in ten years. The regret is real, but so is the choice to parent differently now, even if the internet has not yet agreed on what “gentle” should mean.
More from Decluttering Mom:
