When you’re getting ready for a garage sale, it’s tempting to put out all your old toys to clear space quickly. However, not every toy should be sold this way, as some hold more value or significance than you might realize.
Knowing which old toys to keep rather than sell can save you money and avoid regret later. This guide will help you recognize the kinds of toys you should think twice about before including in your yard sale.
Broken or incomplete LEGO sets
You might think broken or incomplete LEGO sets are worth little, but that’s not always true. Many collectors and builders look for missing pieces or unique parts to complete their own sets.
If you decide to sell, mention any missing or substituted pieces clearly. Buyers appreciate honesty and may still pay for parts they need.
Sometimes, you can find replacement parts online to make a set nearly complete. This can increase its value and appeal, even if the colors don’t match perfectly.
Old stuffed animals with stains
If your old stuffed animals have noticeable stains, it’s best not to sell them at a garage sale. Buyers usually avoid toys that look dirty or worn out.
Stains can also be a sign that the toy may need cleaning or repair before it’s safe for children.
Instead, consider cleaning them gently if possible, or donating only those in good condition. Selling stained stuffed animals can leave a bad impression and reduce the chances of a successful sale.
Vintage board games missing pieces
If you have a vintage board game missing some pieces, don’t be too quick to sell it at a garage sale. These games can still hold value, especially if they are rare or sought after by collectors.
You can often find replacement parts online or from communities of board game enthusiasts. Even with missing pieces, the game might be worth restoring or keeping for nostalgia.
Sometimes, missing parts give you a chance to get creative. You could use the game for DIY projects or as a base to build something new. Just remember, these games often mean more than just the pieces inside.
Battery-operated toys that don’t work
You might have battery-operated toys that no longer work, but don’t rush to sell them. These toys often hold nostalgic value, and with a little effort, you can sometimes fix them. Corroded batteries are a common issue, but cleaning or replacing parts can bring these toys back to life.
Even if you aren’t a tech expert, there are simple steps you can try at home. Repairing these toys can save you money and keep cherished memories intact. Sometimes, the value lies in the potential to restore, not just in the toy’s current condition.
Used baby rattles and teethers
If you have old baby rattles or teethers, you might think a garage sale is a good place to sell them. However, many used rattles and teethers show wear and may not be safe or appealing to buyers.
Some vintage rattles can be collectible, especially if made from silver or unique materials. If yours is handmade or antique, consider selling it online to the right collectors.
For plastic or well-used rattles, donating or recycling might be better options. Selling without knowing their condition or value could leave you disappointed.
