Deputies in Volusia County say a routine welfare check turned into a race to stop a planned murder-suicide, with a great-grandmother allegedly driving around central Florida for hours while her 13-year-old great-granddaughter lay drugged and unresponsive beside her. The girl, who lives with significant disabilities and needs round-the-clock care, survived, and the 69-year-old caregiver now faces attempted murder allegations that have stunned neighbors and family alike. What emerges from the arrest reports is a story of quiet desperation that nearly became a tragedy.
The long drive, the pills, and a teen who could not fight back
Investigators say the day started like many others in DeLand, with 69-year-old Deborah Collier loading her great-granddaughter, Sophia Abbott, into the car for what should have been a routine outing. Instead, according to deputies, Collier spent the day driving the child around Volusia County while allegedly carrying out a plan to end both of their lives. The teen, who has cerebral palsy and relies on others for every basic need, was in no position to resist or even call for help as Collier allegedly gave her pills and kept driving, a detail that underscores just how vulnerable the girl was in that passenger seat.
Authorities later learned that the 13-year-old requires comprehensive, 24-hour care because of her disabilities, and that Collier and her husband had been the primary caregivers responsible for that intense daily workload, according to investigators. Deputies say the situation escalated when relatives grew worried and requested a welfare check, prompting a search that ended with patrol cars surrounding Collier’s vehicle on the side of the road. While Collier appeared calm during the stop, a second deputy noticed that Sophia Abbott was slumped in the passenger seat and unresponsive, a moment later detailed in an account that identified the teen by name and described how Sophia Abbott had to be rushed to intensive care.
Inside the alleged murder-suicide plan and the deputies’ intervention
By the time deputies pulled the car over, the situation was already critical. Reports say the 13-year-old was unresponsive and had to be treated with emergency medication before being taken to a hospital, where she remains in intensive care after what authorities describe as a deliberate overdose attempt. One account notes that the deputies who found the car saw Collier behind the wheel and the teen unresponsive beside her, and that medical staff later confirmed the girl had been given a dangerous mix of prescription pills. Another report describes how a woman in this case is accused of drugging her disabled great-granddaughter as part of an attempted murder-suicide, a charge that tracks with what deputies say they uncovered in the car.
Investigators say they found pills, handwritten notes, and what looked like a clear outline of a plan to die together. Asked about a second letter discovered with the medication, Collier allegedly admitted, “I wrote that yes,” a detail that surfaced when a summary of the case noted how Asked about the note, she acknowledged authorship. Another report describes how a woman from DeLand is accused of trying to kill her disabled great-granddaughter in what deputies call a foiled murder-suicide attempt, and that framing matches the way the Volusia County Sheriff’s Office has characterized the case. A separate account of how Florida deputies stopped a woman in an alleged plan to kill herself and her disabled great-granddaughter notes that she now faces a first-degree attempted murder charge, a key distinction given that the teen survived.
A caregiver at the breaking point and a system stretched thin
Once Collier was in custody, investigators started asking the obvious question: why. According to one report, Collier told investigators she is suicidal after years of hardships and what she described as an unsupportive spouse, and she said the teen is nonverbal and entirely dependent on others. Another account notes that Deborah Collier was the primary caregiver for a great-granddaughter with cerebral palsy, a role that can be physically exhausting and emotionally isolating even in the best-supported families. Put together, the statements paint a picture of a woman who felt trapped and overwhelmed, though none of that excuses what deputies say she chose to do once she got behind the wheel.
Caregiver burnout is not a legal defense, but it is a warning sign that often goes unnoticed until something breaks. In this case, authorities say the break came in the form of a detailed plan, a car packed with pills, and a child who could not speak up for herself. One summary of the arrest notes that Collier was still driving when deputies intercepted her, and another recounts how Collier and her husband had been handling the girl’s 24-hour care largely on their own. The alleged crime forces an uncomfortable conversation about how families caring for children with complex disabilities are supported, or not, and how quickly quiet strain can turn into something far more dangerous when no one steps in early enough.
More from Decluttering Mom:
