You’re seeing more insurers refuse or nonrenew policies because roofs older than certain thresholds raise the risk of costly claims. They flag age, visible wear, and missing maintenance as quick underwriting triggers, which can lead to higher premiums or outright cancellation.
This post explains why companies tighten rules around roof age and how that affects coverage, and it shows practical steps you can take to protect your policy and your wallet. Expect clear guidance on what insurers look for, how to document upkeep, and when a replacement becomes the smarter financial move.
Why Insurance Companies Drop Homes Over Roof Age
Insurers flag roofs that raise the likelihood of a claim, often based on measurable factors like years since installation, visible wear, and material type. They then weigh replacement cost, claim frequency, and regional weather exposure when deciding to nonrenew or decline coverage.
Roof Age and Risk Assessment
Insurance carriers treat roof age as a proxy for failure probability. Many carriers set hard cutoffs — commonly 15–25 years for asphalt shingles — and will mark homes with roofs beyond that range as high risk. Older roofs show higher rates of leaks, structural deterioration, and hidden rot that increase claim frequency.
Underwriting teams combine roof age with local loss history. If a ZIP code has frequent hail or wind losses, an aging roof pushes a property into a higher underwriting tier and may trigger nonrenewal or higher premiums. Policyholders who can produce a recent professional roof inspection or a contractor-issued roof certification often get re-evaluated more favorably.
Impact of Roof Condition and Materials
Condition matters as much as age. Missing shingles, curling edges, granule loss, moss growth, and sagging valleys signal imminent problems and draw insurer scrutiny. An aging roof with visible damage increases the chance of denied claims if the carrier determines damage was pre-existing.
Material type affects longevity and insurer preference. Architectural shingles generally perform better and last longer than 3-tab shingles, which insurers view as thinner and more failure-prone. Metal and tile roofs often receive more favorable treatment, but improper installation or prior storm damage can still trigger coverage issues. Insurers also consider maintenance: documented repairs and regular roof inspections improve underwriting outcomes.
Insurance Company Evaluation Methods
Carriers use a mix of automated data and field verification. Automated checks pull property records, aerial imagery, and age data from tax or MLS records to flag roofs over insurer thresholds. These systems can trigger nonrenewal notices without a prior claim.
After an automated flag, insurers may order a professional roof inspection or request photos. Inspectors look for shingle lift, granule depletion, flashing issues, and interior signs of leaks. Policyholders should obtain a professional roof inspection or contractor report to contest a cancellation. Some homeowners succeed by upgrading shingles (e.g., replacing 3-tab with architectural shingles) and submitting a post-repair inspection to restore coverage.
How Homeowners Can Protect Their Insurance Coverage
Homeowners should focus on concrete steps that keep a roof functional and document those steps for insurers. Doing regular maintenance, making timely repairs, and understanding policy rules reduces the chance of nonrenewal or cancellation.
Proactive Roof Maintenance and Upgrades
They should schedule a professional roof inspection at least once a year and after major storms. Inspections identify missing shingles, granule loss, flashing failures, and areas prone to water intrusion before those problems trigger claims.
Keep a simple maintenance log with dates, contractor names, photos, and invoices. That record helps when an insurer asks for proof of upkeep or when filing a roof-related claim after wind or hail damage. For minor issues—lifted shingles, loose flashing, small leaks—hire a licensed roofing contractor promptly rather than delaying repairs.
When a roof is near the insurer’s age limit, consider targeted upgrades: partial re-roofing of the most damaged slopes, underlayment replacement, or installing impact-resistant shingles. These actions often cost less than full replacement but can improve roof condition and may qualify the home for lower insurance premiums.
Navigating Insurance Policy Changes
They should read the policy’s roof language carefully to learn age limits, material restrictions, and depreciation rules. Some insurers apply steep depreciation to older asphalt roofs; others exclude roofs past a certain year. Knowing these details lets homeowners negotiate or shop with clear expectations.
If an insurer proposes nonrenewal or higher premiums because of roof age, homeowners should request an underwriting inspection report in writing. They can present a recent inspection, maintenance log, and contractor estimates to dispute inaccurate findings. When communicating, keep emails concise and attach dated photos showing repairs or replaced sections.
Compare quotes from at least three carriers if a policy change seems likely. Some regional insurers or specialty markets cover homes with older roofs at competitive rates, especially if the homeowner has upgraded to high-performance materials or completed recent repairs.
Options After Policy Cancellation
If a policy gets canceled or nonrenewed, act fast to avoid a coverage gap. First, confirm the cancellation reason and the effective date, then immediately obtain written documentation and any inspection reports the insurer used. Lenders often require proof of replacement coverage to avoid force-placed insurance.
Next, get multiple replacement quotes and provide evidence of repairs or a contractor’s timeline to prospective insurers. If standard carriers decline, check the state’s assigned risk pool or a residual market plan; those programs accept higher-risk homes but usually at higher premiums.
They can also prioritize repairs that insurers commonly require—replace severely deteriorated shingles, fix active leaks, and secure loose flashing—then ask insurers to re-evaluate. For homes in hurricane or severe-weather zones, installing wind-rated shingles or secondary water barriers can improve insurability and reduce future roof-related claims.
More from Decluttering Mom: